Ideally I want the user to be blindfolded and knowingly in the company of character 1. Character 1 then brings character 2 in without user's knowledge. Character 2 engages with user while user believes its actually character 1.

The only way I can think of to make this work would be to swap the users and one of the characters. So it would be Character 1 blindfolded while user and Character 2 engage.

It's a problematic situation because I want to take the role of the blindfolded person, but I don't see any way a bot could adequately roleplay the other 2 characters being sneaky, etc. It doesn't help that since I made it, I know what's going to happen.