I remember this was a big thing way back in the early Challenge (BotS1) days. I wanted to be a bit nostalgic and bring back that interactive MTV poll they had on the website.

Who was right? Julie or Melissa? After their rise to fame on the Real World, contestants Melissa and Julie were both doing college lectures at universities for extra money. Melissa claimed her agent told her, that Julie (or someone in her team), was telling colleges not to book her for speaking engagements. Because she didn't sign autographs and her fee was too high.

While Julie claims that she does sign autographs and her appearance fee IS lower. Its believed that Julie’s team does her bookings. Melissa claims that Julie stole opportunities from her because of this. Is this true? Or was Julie just smart and marketed her self accordingly? Who was right?

View Poll