Coming soon - Get a detailed view of why an account is flagged as spam!
view details

This post has been de-listed

It is no longer included in search results and normal feeds (front page, hot posts, subreddit posts, etc). It remains visible only via the author's post history.

2
Lord's Reform Results
Post Body

Evening everyone,

The results have now been counted and are outlined in full below.

So without further ado let’s get stuck into them.


IRV Ballot


There were 60 valid votes cast for the IRV ballot. One vote was unverified and was therefore discarded. Also one vote was placed after the voting deadline had passed and was therefore also discarded.


Round 1

Status Quo: 16

Abolishment of the Lords: 17

DF Proposal: 14

Brookheimer’s Proposal: 4

Comped’s Proposal: 5

Jas’ Proposal: 4


Tie between Brookheimer’s Proposal and Jas’ Proposal on first preference votes. As Brookheimer’s Proposal has more 2nd preference votes that proposal will continue and Jas’ Proposal is eliminated.


Round 2

Status Quo: 17 ( 1)

Abolishment of the Lords: 18 ( 1)

DF’s Proposal: 14

Brookheimer’s Proposal: 5 ( 1)

Comped’s Proposal: 6 ( 1)


Brookheimer’s Proposal is eliminated.


Round 3

Status Quo: 18 ( 1)

Abolishment of the Lords: 18

DF’s Proposal: 17 ( 3)

Comped’s Proposal: 7 ( 1)


Comped’s Proposal is eliminated.


Round 4

Status Quo: 22 ( 4)

Abolishment of the Lords: 18

DF’s Proposal: 20 ( 3)


Abolishment of the Lords is eliminated.


Round 5

Status Quo: 24 ( 2)

DF’s Proposal: 36 ( 16)


DF’s Proposal wins.


Secondary Ballot


There were 58 valid votes cast for the Secondary ballot. One vote was unverified and was therefore discarded. Also one vote was placed after the voting deadline had passed and was therefore also discarded.


Activity Reviews in the Lord's should include AP's

Yes: 32

No: 17

Abstain: 9


This Proposal has therefore passed.


AP's who fail an Activity Review should not be able to swear into the Lords's again for a set period of time

Yes: 32

No: 21

Abstain: 5


This Proposal has therefore passed.


Lord's should be able to vote upon votes that are ongoing upon their swearing in

Yes: 28

No: 24

Abstain: 6


This Proposal has therefore passed.


All members should be able to comment within the Lords

Yes: 17

No: 33

Abstain: 8


This Proposal has therefore failed.


Abolish Lord's Bills and Motions

Yes: 20

No: 34

Abstain: 4


This Proposal has therefore failed.


PNQ's should always go to a follow up debate

Yes: 31

No: 16

Abstain: 11


This Proposal has therefore passed.


Increase the use of OQ's from the Leader of the Lords, with opportunities for other Ministers to participate if required

Yes: 40

No: 10

Abstain: 8


This Proposal has therefore passed.


Congratulations to those whose proposals have passed.

With these results my part in this process is now completed. The implementation, and the upcoming LS election, will now be handled by the Quadrumvirate in the near future.

Author
Account Strength
90%
Account Age
11 years
Verified Email
Yes
Verified Flair
No
Total Karma
2,858
Link Karma
1,981
Comment Karma
822
Profile updated: 3 days ago
Posts updated: 7 months ago
His Grace the Duke of Wellington | Guardian

Subreddit

Post Details

We try to extract some basic information from the post title. This is not always successful or accurate, please use your best judgement and compare these values to the post title and body for confirmation.
Posted
4 years ago