I’ve written about the first true MFM experience my wife, Anna, and I had, but that was actually our second attempt. The first time around things started off great but took a very odd turn.

The other man involved in this, let’s call him Clark, originally matched with me on Feeld. His profile said he was bisexual, but I always assumed that men matching with me on Feeld are really just trying to get to Anna who is pictured on my profile. Still, I was intrigued because he seemed like someone Anna would like, and I’ve always been a little bi-curious so I figured that was another avenue we could potentially explore. I had experimented with another man a little when I was much younger, but had pushed all those feelings down for decades. Still, I was open to exploring them in the again in the right situation.

I started chatting with him and quickly got the impression that he was interested in playing solo with Anna and then potentially also joining both of us. That was still perfectly OK with me (Anna and I both play solo most of the time) but I told him that he’d need to wow her for it to work. She’s very picky, as she should be, and likes a confident man who can make her laugh and stimulate her mind. They connected on Feeld and hit it off almost immediately.

Anna was kind of crushing on Clark, and after they connected I didn’t hear from him again. Their sexting kept escalating, but arranging a meeting was proving difficult. Clark was in the process of relocating back to our area from the Northeast, and on top of that it was the holiday season. They kept in touch every day and figured they’d find time to meet after the holidays.

After weeks of back and forth, he finally proposed a time he was free. To our surprise, however, he wanted to meet both of us first, and if anything were to progress from there, he wanted it to be with both of us.

This was surprising because he had said the opposite when we first started talking to him, but the idea of a MFM was exciting because we hadn’t done one before. Anna was very hot at the thought of having two men to please her and take turns filling her holes. She would talk about it with both Clark and I. She wanted it badly. We both got a little nervous and excited as the date drew closer.

We decided we’d meet him for a drink at a nearby bar and let Anna decide whether or not she wanted to proceed. If so, we’d bring him back to the house to have a drink by the fire pit on the back patio and then move things to the bedroom where I had prepared toys, restraints, lube, etc. He arrived at the bar and we both liked him immediately. He looked like we expected, was smart, funny, and just gave off a good vibe. As we finished our drinks Anna suggested that we move things back to our place.

He asked if he should just follow us there in his car, but I suggested that Anna ride with him so he didn’t get lost. I figured they could maybe start a little touching and kissing in the car at a red light or something. I drove ahead to the house to get the fire going and some drinks poured ahead of their arrival. I had just finished pouring the drinks when they walked in the side gate together.

Stay tuned for part 2…