Tier Lists are pretty overdone I know, but I feel like now is a pretty good time with the gap in albums. I've been a fan since 2020 right before Eric left the band.

S - Near constant rotation, every song continuously feels like a reward. There isn't a single song on any of these that I dislike. Depending on the day, I would probably rank Butterfly 3000 top 3.

Also I love Butterfly 3001 a ton, some of the remixes are even better than the original.

A - MOST of the songs are great. The majority of their albums fall here for me, where about 90% is good but I'll usually skip one or two songs. I feel like most of these aren't very controversial, except 12 Bar Bruise. I'm a big fan of early Osees and other adjacent stuff, so I find this album super charming. A great start for the band.

Cowboy Tier - Accidentally put Paper Mache there but I meant to put it above 12 Bar actually oops lol

B - These albums have good songs but I don't usually enjoy a front to back listen. I'm sad that Float Along ended up landing this low, but they just have too much solid shit released.

The reason Mind Fuzz is so low is because I find the production to be kind of grating, especially when every song on the album is just 200% better live.

C - The weak links. I do enjoy most of Willoughby's Beach and Oddments, but Quarters is one that I can't seem to ever enjoy. Even The River has got a little stale to me at this point.

I was feeling bored so felt like making this list and post, I want to hear other people's thoughts :)