So my wife has really warmed up to the idea of a threesome involving another woman since we started our journey of sharing her with other men. We pulled the trigger this past Saturday and it wasn’t the cornucopia of awesome that I expected or that I remembered from previous experiences when I was younger. We found her on Feeld. She was in town for the weekend and after chatting we decided to make a move and host her. Leading up to her arriving my wife kept asking me if I was ok. I guess she could tell that I was a little unsure or at least a little off. I explained to her all the thoughts that were going through my head “What if she isn’t as attractive as I thought?”, “What if she doesn’t find me or the wife attractive?”, “What if she and I find each other TOO attractive?”, “What should I wear?” Or “How do I balance giving them both the right amount of attention?”. My wife responded with “welcome to my world. No matter how many times I’m with another man; all those things and more make me super nervous”. The wife enjoyed watching me squirm beforehand, I think. She came over later that evening. Showed up in a robe with lingerie underneath, which was a plus. Loved the enthusiasm. We all sat around and drank for a bit to get to know each other and establish comfort levels. My wife was also in her customary robe with lingerie underneath and completely out shined our unicorn if you ask my opinion. When it was clear we were all interested and it was time to proceed; I joined the ladies on the couch with our playmate between my wife and I. We started with the ladies making out and I joined shortly after. We moved the party to the bedroom and really got going with acting out virtually any fantasy the three of us had. The two of them sharing my cock in a blowjob will be a personal highlight the rest of my life. After it was all said and done, the toys were washed and packed, the sheets were cleaned, and the goodbyes were said. It just overall wasn’t that great. There are several reasons I can come up with for it not being the earth shattering experience we both thought it might be, but the most obvious is that it just didn’t do it for me. There were little things from her perfume, to the way she kissed, to the way her pussy felt that just didn’t feel right and just didn’t turn me on. I could only truly maintain an erection when my wife was directly involved with me. Maybe it’s just that she wasn’t my wife. Who knows? The sex and arousal level during and after was nothing like we experience when we invite a male third to share and enjoy the wife. We captured some decent pictures and will certainly give it another go, most likely with a couple, but it really feels like Hotwifing is what does it for me and even having two women pales in comparison.