I’d been pursuing something like this, on and off, for a few months until CL shut down the personals. I was eager for my first Hotwife experience. Perhaps too eager when he responded to one of my posts weeks ago.

Said he and his wife would be visiting my city and he was interested in setting something up. I confirmed availability and interest and general scenario. We agreed a day/time to grab dinner and leave the evening open.

On their arrival date, we reconfirmed our date for the following evening. I suggested we trade pics so we would recognize each other, and confirm our mutual interest. I immediately received a few pics and a note asking if I was ok with an Indian couple.

So I confirm my interest and he replies that she wants a full body picture from me. I send it along and receive an enthusiastic reply.

Next evening, we meet up at the restaurant. This is our first face-to-face and where I begin to get a strange vibe. She is not at all talkative, and he is happy to answer for her. I’m trying to get her to open up, chatting with her directly, but getting only short answers. I want her to feel comfortable and this is getting nowhere, so I lighten up, let things flow. We stick to idle chit chat, nothing sexual. She is almost silent.

After dinner, we head to my house. I welcome them inside and he instantly asks me what I think of her tits. Being a gentleman, I put a hand on her shoulder, look her in the eyes and tell her what a wonderful looking woman she is. He reaches over, grabs a boob, and tells me “she’s got great tits.” She remains silently smiling.

I offer to “show them around” and we make our way to the bedroom. He tells me “she needs a nice massage” as she strips off her top and dress. I grab a towel and some oil and get to work. He sits down, crosses his arms across his chest and just watches as I rub her down from shoulders to toes. I flip her over on her back and start on her boobs. Same smile across her face.

I drip oil across my hands and her pussy, and begin to give her a nice pussy massage and she finally begins to respond with some low moans. She grabs my cock and is stroking me almost absent mindedly. After she cums the first time, he says “ok, now just fuck her good, she’s ready.” Well, I begin to finger her instead and she is finally beginning to arch her back and moan audibly as I hit her G spot, then cums the second time. He repeats himself “she’s ready, just fuck her.”

And so I do. And I must admit it’s just about the most unsatisfying sex I’ve ever experienced. She’s just laying there, eyes closed. I flip her around into different positions and reach around to rub her clit. This goes on for what seems like forever with very little response from her aside from the occasional moan and shudder. At one point I whisper in her ear; “I know you like it when strangers want you” and she whispers back “he does.”

Soon, he walks up to the head of the bed. She’s on her back, feet over my shoulders and she reaches out and starts rubbing him through his pants as I pound her. They are looking at each other now. And I’m honestly just not feeling it. I need some enthusiasm on the part of my partner, I need to hear feedback, and I’m getting nothing, besides him saying “yeah, fuck her good!”

So I’ve about had it, but I’m nowhere close to cumming. So I guess you could say I faked an orgasm. I increased my pace, tightened my grip, started moaning. I let out one good moan and stop pumping. They are still staring at each other, she’s fondling his dick in his pants. I pull out, get up and remove the condom. They don’t know what is or is not in there. I grab a wipe and “clean up.”

Meanwhile, he’s unzipping and removing his pants, keeps his shirt and socks on and mounts her. He cums within five seconds, gets off her and asks for some water. I go to the kitchen to grab some water bottles. By the time I turn around, he has walked out of the bedroom fully dressed. I hand him water and she’s now dressed so I give her a bottle too. He starts to the door, she grabs her purse and follows. At the door, he turns and thanks me for a wonderful evening, I give her a hug, they get into their rent-a-car and leave.

So how can I improve for the next time? Should I have just walked away from dinner when I first got a bad vibe? Should I make sure to text her directly to get a sense of her personality in advance? What other suggestions do you have to make the next experience a better one? Thanks