We had an absolutely mind blowing experience the first time we ever did this. The guy was built like a Greek god and might have had the most perfect looking big dick I've ever seen.

My wife went absolutely crazy for him and the guy fucked like he was built from God for the very purpose of giving women orgasms. I cant even exaggerate how good this guy was. It was clearly the best fuck of her life and the guy is definitely the hottest guy she's ever had.

We still both cum regularly to the memory of that night. We tried to hook back up with him several times but our schedules never matched and he moved away.

Now years later, we crave another night like that but feel like it would never match that first experience and worry if we do it with another guy, we would be setting ourselves up for disappointment because the first guy was a sex god basically.

Anyone else experienced this?