Tomorrow we have a hardwood floor contractor coming to begin he process of refinishing our original 1930s hardwood floors. He’s one of those guys that doesn’t seem to want to give any recommendations, just all the options. We still haven’t decided whether to replace or try to preserve the baseboards.

All baseboards are of the same style in the house. However, it appears to be a mixture of MDF and some other type of hardwood, redwood or mahogany. My guess is maybe 2-3 out of 5 rooms have original hardwood trim. That base has many layers of paint. Nothing ornate. Shoe molding everywhere. Plaster walls.

I have no emotional attachment to them, but I feel like some folks view the old stuff as “expensive” and you should save what you can. But I just want it all to be clean and consistent.

One room had carpet so the base has to come off because it’s raised. 3 other sections are damaged and would require new runs (6-12ft sections). So I am replacing ~15% anyway.

I’m not opposed to saving money either. Would removing just the shoe molding and refinishing up to the base be a smart choice? This could save money on trim, labor, and wall patching. But looking for all recommendations.