As the title suggests, I have this vivid memory of seeing this rubbery, smooth, gel-like toy at Walmart. But none of my roommates remember it. It was just there in the checkout aisle without packaging. I remember it so well because it had such an odd, off-putting texture. We each touched it and had the same disgusted (yet oddly fascinated) reaction. It didn't have little beads in it like a stress ball. It was semi-floppy like a thick pancake, and you could probably make slappy sounds with it. I've Googled it to death, but all the results are all wrong:

• It rested on its flat back, not upright
• It's not plush or stuffed. It's just smooth, kind of rubbery-feeling, and with a gel-like density
• It's not slow rising. When you touch it, it dents in, but then it just goes back to its normal shape.
• It's not rainbow poo, sparkly poo, or anything else. It's just the standard brown.
• It's not small. It was about the size of two adult hands.

I know it's a long shot, but I just thought I'd try. Thanks!