Things we know that are cannon from either Vivienne Medrano, the pilot or the Prime tv season 1: •Eve and Lilith were the first women and very easily could be identical images of each other •Lilith and Alastor have been “gone” for seven years •Alastor made a deal and is “on a chain” himself •Lute refers to a woman as Lilith, and this woman looks visibly upset afterwards

Lyrics from Alastor’s song: “Let’s begin. I’m gonna make you wish that I’d stayed gone. Tune on in. When I’m done, your status quo will know its race is run. Oh, it will be fun.”

Theory: Alastor originally wanted to make a deal with Lilith and went searching for seven years to find her. Ultimately he found Eve trapped in hell and made a deal: power for help reclaiming her place in heaven.

Lilith made a deal with Lute to trade places with Eve, conversely, Eve has made a deal with Alastor.

Sera has been suspicious of “Eve” but had no proof of this switch as good stays in heaven and evil stays in hell. But when Sir Pentious ascends to heaven, her fears of Lilith residing in heaven become a very real possibility.

When “Lilith” becomes upset with Lute, it could hint to Lite blackmailing her secret in order to keep her in line.

During the song Alastor sings, he is singing to Lilith and telling her that his and Eve’s revenge plot is beginning.