This post has been de-listed
It is no longer included in search results and normal feeds (front page, hot posts, subreddit posts, etc). It remains visible only via the author's post history.
I found myself pretty much in full agreement with Ham on this one, he asked many of the same questions I would have. Tao seems to base his whole worldview around what he wants to be true / what makes him feel happy and then convinces himself that he came to these conclusions through reason. It's also funny to me that his experience with DMT, putting a physical material into his brain to change his perception, made him think materialism is invalid. I also disagree with his stance that without a belief in a spiritual dimension all we have is nihilism. I actually feel that believing in a separate higher spiritual dimension that's somehow more meaningful and important is nihilistic because it robs this immediate and real world of meaning. I feel my life is deeply meaningful even though I don't believe in a god or afterlife or some grand plan. People complain, well then what's the point of life!? Life doesn't need a point!
Although I have thought of myself as a "spiritual" person but this episode had me rethink my choice of words. I am an Atheist and materialist although I do entertain the possibility of panpsychism. And like most of you I've taken a ton of psychedelic and dissociative drugs and experienced subjective phenomena that people usually consider supernatural or to contradict materialism. But I feel similarly suspicious to Ham of our tendency to anthropomorphize and project our own nature onto everything else. I don't believe in spirits or gods but I do derive an intense sense of awe and wonder from the mysterious nature of existence. So I've decided that the term mystical is better fitting, I'm a mystical Atheist haha!
My personal take on spirituality is the same as Panspermia: I don't think it's wrong but in itself doesn't really add anything meaningful to our attempts at explaining the world. It just kicks the questions down the road.
As in.
I see no meaningful, practical difference between your consciousness being an emergent property of your brain or the result of higher dimensional energies.
It's a What not a Why.
An incomprehensible deity's inscrutable will and an incomprehensible Cosmos indifferent happenstance have both the exact same bearing on the lack/presence of meaningfulness of my moment to moment existence.
The true purpose of life is discovery
Spiritual realities might exist. But if so they're simply just another facet of the universe to discover, study and harness rather than a purpose in itself.
An ornithologist is given purpose by cataloguing birds. The anatomy of a new species of penguin doesn't reveal more about the scientist's purpose. Instead it's the discovery itself that does.
By the same token, a prophet understanding her god's will is the purpose of her life. Not what purpose the god assigns to her.
So no.
Most religions ultimately just state that god/consciousness was bored which is why things exist now.
That's about as meaningful as a purely material Basis of reality.
Whether or not we're nihilist depends entirely on us.
Subreddit
Post Details
- Posted
- 4 months ago
- Reddit URL
- View post on reddit.com
- External URL
- reddit.com/r/HamiltonMor...