The wiki states he is collecting 2 Minotaur Horns per gift this week. This is my first time ever getting Nick gifts so if there are quirks to the delivery, I'm not sure. I did google search my issue with no results.

I have 4 Minotaur Horns. My inventory is not full. He appears in the correct spot but when I go to talk to him he simply pops up some dialogue wishing to see me next week, as if I've hit my limit of gifts for the week. As I said, this is my first time ever doing Nick so that is definitely not the case.

I have re-zoned. My inventory is not full. I have no quests affecting the area.

Any ideas?

Edit: People had some great ideas that sounded like great solutions. Unfortunately, none of them solved the problem, so far.

• I tried moving them to different slots.

• Different bags.

• Dropped them and picked them up.

• Used different character.

Nothing worked, sadly :(