Coming soon - Get a detailed view of why an account is flagged as spam!
view details
84
[effort] GamerGate's latest Wikipedia War shows how GG crowdsources harassment
Author Summary
Wrecksomething is in Effort
Post Body

GamerGate's latest "Arbitration Request" is 15,000 words and climbing. That's about 60 typed, double-spaced pages. That's not counting the dozens (hundreds?) of hyperlinks you have to read to digest it.

It owes its size to 8chan canvasing for "meatpuppets" to target specific editors.

DIG UP ALL INFO POSSIBLE ON Ryulong, NorthBySouthBarnoff, TarainDC, and TheRedPenofDoom.

SCOUR TWITTER, TUMBLR, WORDPRESS, ANYTHING FOR RYULONG, TARAINDC, THEREDPENOFDOOM, OR NORTHBYHEADUPASS

Their users dutifully dredged up countless old, investigated and already settled accusations, and material not appropriate for Arbitration.

It's 8chan so they also connected those editors to real life names, twitter accounts, patreon accounts, and email addresses. 8chan:

Who is [First and last name, redacted] on wikipedia?

Ryufag. I think. Maybe dreadfag or whatever. Their names are shit.

More [Last name, redacted] & LW Twitter buddying

Archived! [Last name] supports LW on Patreon

I'm trying to decypher that string now. I want to see if he's a sex offender.

When this all spread to KotakuInAction I sent reddit admins a PM in case the personal info dumps offended them; it is still up though.

Likewise, the Arbitration Request leverages their army to Gish Gallup. Indeed the request does not make any specific complaints:

a simple review of the linked discussions above should illustrate what conduct issues are in question here with regards to you and other parties to this request. Laying out all of them personally would be taxing

True, it is taxing to review. Each time GG pulls this stunt, its targets expend massive effort debunking them. Example, read starting at

Yeah TDA, sure, if it's too taxing for you, I'll do it. [...]

and see that GG hasn't won a single of these requests yet, instead often gets themselves banned ("BOOMERANG") because the requests are so abusive. But GG is very fond of referencing its numerous failed attempts as evidence that its targets are always in trouble.

what is it the 4th ANI you got this month? Can any admin tell me with a straight face that his behaviour is acceptable?

Wiki admins are understandably frustrated (my emphasis):

a lot of people have already commented ... to avoid making this page an unreadable wall of text, I'm asking everyone to please stick to the rules and be careful not to use more than 500 words in their statements. If you have used more, please shorten your statement in a reasonable amount of time, or it will have to be removed in its entirety.

A main Gator has a comment over 2,000 words. Yikes.

One serious problem is that "Arbitration" (which is a high-level conflict resolution tool) is "not ripe."

The previous request was dismissed as "too soon" to to see if the existing community processes could handle the situation. I am not aware that there has been any attempt to utilize the existing community processes since that time

The last ArbCom request closed less than a week ago, and all of the discussions linked to above are from September and October, before the request closed. As far as I am aware there have been no significant events on the GamerGate article

GG is trying to bypass Wikipedia's rules and processes to escalate. It seems admins might grant the request (so far 0 in favor/opposed) to try to stem the drama, but they don't want to reward the escalation.

... might seem to point to the fact that the community cannot successfully deal with this dispute and that it would probably be a good idea for ArbCom to step in. At the same time, I don't want to give the impression that by failing to drop a stick, someone can force us to take a case ...

But perhaps the main takeaway? This is a typical day in a 3-month ordeal on Wikipedia. It must be exhausting, which GG must know, and they're going out of their way to make it harder by not respecting any rules.

Author
Account Strength
100%
Account Age
11 years
Verified Email
Yes
Verified Flair
No
Total Karma
292,880
Link Karma
7,987
Comment Karma
282,496
Profile updated: 2 days ago
Posts updated: 10 months ago
scope shill

Subreddit

Post Details

Location
We try to extract some basic information from the post title. This is not always successful or accurate, please use your best judgement and compare these values to the post title and body for confirmation.
Posted
10 years ago