Fatima has perhaps had one of the best character developments going from a social rock in Fromville and being someone new people turn to so that they can settle quickly and with hope.

To now a broken shell of a person devoid of everything we saw in Season 1. She has a seemingly phantom pregnancy, is dieting of rotten food, is having body altering visions aswell as seeing things externally too and you are all judging how she is a terrible person or just simply "annoying".

And this isn't even taking into consideration the monsters, talismans, people dying around her etc.

Elgin on the other hand is creepy. Lacks a spine. I get literal weasel vibes from him and he has done nothing since arriving to even gain likability...