I'm a 27 yr old straight acting gay guy, though I'm exploring my bi side these days. Back in my undergrad days I had a lot of sex and met a lot of dudes. It was the middle of winter in upstate NY 2018, and there wasn't much to do. So... a low cost option was to scroll apps and meet some guys.

One night, I was particularly bored in my off-campus apartment. I invited over a guy who we'll call Jack. Jack was a slim build, curly haired college boy who was non-binary. Me being on the masculine side and very horny this night, I wanted to do more than hang. We hung out in my room sitting on my bed while leaning back on our hands, and talked about college, life, dating. He was in an open relationship, and so we were following the friends or fwbs vibe. An hour or so rolled by, and I had started to get insanely horny for no reason. I had warned Jack before he came over that I wasn't shy, and he made it clear he was not worried. So, I let me horniness show, and he could see my cock through my shorts. While we were chatting, I started flexing it and occasionally brushing it with my hands.

Eventually he glanced down, and said "looks like you've got something there.." to which I laughed and maybe blushed ;). After a bit of coyness, I stood up in front of Jack and slid my shorts completely off. My dick snagged as the shorts went down, and bobbed a few times which caused a string of precum to swing from my tip. He quickly stood off the bed and dropped to the floor. He used his tongue to lick up my precum and started giving me sloppy, amazing head. I was definitely holding myself back from cumming at this point.

A bit passes, and he tries to ride me while facing me. He goes for a bit, but gets a bit too sore. So I pull out and jerk myself off behind his ass, while he continues jerking while sitting on me. In a matter of minutes he starts to shoot so much cum it's almost like he's pissing. He soaks my chest, my face, my pillows, the wall. And while he's still draining, I cum all over his bubble butt.

After this, we lay in our mess for a few minutes. He tells me he hosts game nights at his house with him and a few friends. He says I should come to one sometime. Now the real story...

A few weeks pass, and one Friday night I get an invite to go hang at his place for a game night. I'm not big into the super complex games, but he mentioned that the game nights get handsy, and me being infinitely horny, decided to join. When I arrive, its Jack, his bf Daniel, their gay roommate Brian, their gay friend Luke, and their straight roommate Mark. Mark was by far the cutest guy there. A 5'8, brown haired brown eyed guy, with an angular face, deep voice, and slim, toned build. We all made some drinks and then sat down at their dining room table to play a game called Scythe, which I had never heard of. Mark is sitting to my right, and the rest of the guys are sitting across the table.

We play for about an hour, they've been great at guiding me through the gameplay, but I am quickly failing. So Jack says "Looks like you're struggling, would you like some help?" to which I quickly retorted, "yes." He smirks up at me from across the table and says, "Well, help is gonna cost you a dare." I chuckle and say "Oh great, what's the dare." He immediately tells me that if I want his help to stay in the game, I have to strip naked for the rest of the game. Now again, I am not shy. I felt a bit nervous because of Mark being next to me. After a few seconds of grimacing I said "I'm not shy, that's not too hard", which was the wrong thing to say. Jack added to the dare by saying, "sure, but you have to also stay hard the entire time you're naked."

At this point I rolled my eyes, shook my head and said, "bro, that's not fucking fair. You know I'd basically have to edge while we play. I'm not shy and I totally would, but I don't want to freak out Mark", as I glanced to my right. The guys across the table laugh, and as they do Mark says, "dude, I'm not your scapegoat, I don't care." I swallow my spit, my heart pounding. The guys refill their drinks, and after a few minutes, we go to resume the game. I burst out and say "fuck it" and take off my shirt. The guys exclaim and make noise in support, and I think their shock. I then stand up, unzip my jeans, and take my jeans/trunks straight off. I'm already semi because of the thrill, but I immediately scoot my chair back from the table, sit down, and give my cock a few tugs. Within seconds I'm throbbing and so nervous I could puke. Mark is just casually sitting next to me... wtf

We resume the game. I slowly jerk while its not my turn, and take quick breaks to play. It was not an issue to stay hard. I got so horny. The kind of horny where your balls and taint start to ache. After about an hour, I'm leaking so much precum that you'd think I was using lube. My entire shaft and balls were slick, and the upholstery of their chairs was darkened from my wet balls resting on the fabric. At this point, Jack and Brian would periodically come to my side of the table and give me a hand. Daniel came over between one of his turns and went down on me in front of the group, and I had to shove him off of me before I gave him a mouthful. Near the end of the game, Luke came over to my left, pulled down his pants, and let me rub his hole. His cock was very hard, and was resting on the table and gameboard. We continued this for another two hours until the game ended. Me still naked, hard, and yet to cum.

Its about 1 AM, and we as a group go upstairs to play some Jack Box Games in their office. I decided to stay naked, as it didn't matter at this point. Jack, Daniel, Brian, Luke, and I sit on a futon they have, while Mark sits next to us in a desk chair. We have our legs up on their ottoman. I'm sandwiched between Brian and Luke, who are simultaneously rubbing me down. Massaging my pecs and thighs, stroking my cock, grabbing my balls. It doesn't take long before I lift their shirts, which avalanches to everyone on the couch stripping their clothes off. Four naked dudes, and straight, clothed Mark off in his chair. Luke gets on all fours on the ottoman and all but with words, invites me to his ass. I get on the floor, put my entire face in between his muscled cheeks, and start eating away. I guess this must have been hot to see, because Jack, Daniel, and Brian follow suit; Jack on all fours on the couch, Brian, Daniel, and Luke on the ottoman, Mark in the chair. I continue rimming each of them. Feeling them up, moving to the next, fingering the last.

At this point, nobody is playing and Mark puts on car and music videos on YouTube, but continues to stay in his chair, vibin' out. I honestly can't tell you how I haven't cum at this point, but I'm still locked and loaded. We push the ottoman against the couch, and I get all four guys side by side, with their heads at a bias towards Mark. And at this point.... I'm fingering Brian and Luke while my face is buried in Jacks bubble butt. I scoot up and kneel behind him, rubbing my tip on his hole while I keep fingering the others. Without intention, I push just a bit harder than I meant, and I slipped right into Jack. My rimming must have relaxed him. From here, I'm pounding each of these guys, fingering and feeling the others, pulling out and resting so I don't cum. And this goes on and on for maybe an hour. Three of the guys wind up cumming on the couch and ottoman (it was ruined for sure). At this point I'm in Luke, wiping up their cum and spreading it on their abs, pecs, asses, and my body. I can barely hold back, so my rest periods are getting longer and my pounding is getting shorter. I go in one last time and I must have done one thrust too many. I pull out immediately to try and save it, but I just start spraying. I've literally never cum like that. Maybe 15 watery jets of cum pump out. I spray all four guys, their couch, and with the distance, some cum landed on Mark's leg.

Again, I never wanted to make Mark uncomfortable and this -while hot now- made me so nervous that my body was jittery. To my surprise, Mark just looked over with a snarky glare and said "bro, aim your firehose a different way next time."

After that, we all took turns rinsing off, and then passed out while watching Anime together.

Aside from using aliases, this story is a recount of an unintentional orgy... haha

So... what would you have done?

!Unlock