“I know how this goes. You’re just going to give me some pity fuck and then you’ll go tell your friends how awful it was.” Will retorted. 

“What do you mean?” I said with a sharp tone.

“I know about Ryan and Derek,” he blurted out. 

“What about them?” I asked in an increasingly angry tone.

“I know you refused to fuck Ryan and then you pitty fucked Derek.” Will quipped. 

“A pity fuck?!” I asked, now full blown angry that Derek was telling people I had sex with him out of pity. 

“If it was such a pity fuck, then why did I have sex with him last night?” I retorted. 

Will froze, “You did?”

“Yes! I did!” I screamed. 

“Oh…” Will said as his confidence immediately deflated. 

“And Ryan… That was my first night here. I was overwhelmed and having sex with anyone was the last thing on my mind.” I continued in my angry tone. 

“I’m sorry. I didn’t know that.” Will apologized.

 “Obviously.” I snapped back. 

“Look. I’m okay not having sex. To be blunt, I’ve had a lot of sex in the last 24 hours. I would be totally okay not doing anything tonight.” I said as I stood up from the bench.

“However, the offer is still on the table. Take it or leave it. You know where to find me.” I continued as I stormed back inside the cabin and straight to the last open bedroom. 

I laid on the bed with my arms folded in anger. I could hear the muffled noises of people having sex in the rooms adjacent to me. 

I could hear Chloe’s familiar voice moan “Oh, Alex!”

It reminded me that she was with my ex-boyfriend tonight. 

Ugh. I grunted under my breath as mental images of my ex-boyfriend fucking Chloe filled my imagination. 

“Oh fuck! Oh god!” I heard another female voice scream. I tried to figure out who it could be. It didn’t sound like any of my friends.

“Oh Greg!” the voice screamed.

That must be Yasmin. I thought to myself.

I was taken back to my threesome with Greg a few days earlier. The feeling of his cock sliding in and out of me. His balls slapped against me as he slid his member in and out of me while I was bent over the bed. My mind drifted to what it would look like to see his cock sliding in and out of Yasmin’s vagina. The hairy lips of her labia give way to Greg’s dick. 

I could feel a wetness forming between my legs and my hand instinctively drifted down my body and towards my pussy. My petite index finger began rubbing circles over my clit as my mind raced between images of Alex pounding Chloe and Yasmin riding Greg. 

I was taken back to the other day and the feeling of Greg’s dick inside me.

God, I want some dick… I thought to myself. Considering I had had my fair share of dick over the last day I was surprised by my thoughts. 

My breathing began to intensify as I added a second finger rubbing my clit. 

Suddenly the bedroom door creaked open. I pulled my hand away from my vagina and returned to my original position. Laying on the bed, my arms crossed across my chest. 

I saw Will sneak into the bedroom, surprised to see the lights were still on and that I was laying silently on the bed. We looked into each other’s eyes in a sort of standoff - waiting for the other to speak first.

“Uh… I’m… Uh… Sorry for being so harsh.” Will stuttered as he broke the silence between us. 

“It’s okay, Will.” 

“It is?”

“Yes, I know I haven’t been perfect and some of your criticism is deserved.” I begrudgingly admitted. 

“Oh.” was all Will said in response as another silence fell between us. 

Once again we were locked into a standoff. Each of us was staring at the other. I could sense that Will wanted to say something else. His 6 foot frame awkwardly stood there leaning back against the door to the bedroom. His hands down in front of his crotch, continuing to hide his dick from my view. His pale skin was dotted with freckles and sharply contrasted against his red hair. 

Inside I was conflicted. On one hand, I was pretty sore and tired. Especially after having sex with Chris and Matt almost back to back. On the other hand, I was getting more turned on by the idea of taking Will’s virginity. 

This time I decided to break the silence. 

“So?” I asked, “Do you want to have sex?” 

It was straight to the point. No fluff. No games. 

“Uh… Do you?” Will said.

“Will… I wouldn’t be asking if I wasn’t interested.” I quipped back. 

“Oh uh… I guess that makes sense…” He mumbled as his hand shifted, trying to hide his growing erection. 

“Well… Do you?” I asked.

Will silently nodded as his gaze once again shifted to the ground. 

I guess I need to take the lead here. I thought to myself as I got up off the bed and walked towards Will. 

As I approached him he was trembling with nervous anticipation. I knew this was going to have to be a slow and gentle process.

“Have you ever kissed?” I asked softly.

Will, still looking at the ground, shook his head no. 

I gently lifted his chin so he was looking at me, leaned in, and put my lips on his. I could feel a slight tremble in his lips as our lips touched. I pulled away.

“Relax.” I whispered. 

Will nodded his head and I wrapped my arms around his neck and pulled him into me for another kiss. Will finally moved his hands from his dick as he tried to rebalance himself. When he did, I took a step forward, closing the gap between our bodies and making it nearly impossible for Will to cover his dick again. 

We stood there in the doorway making out. At first, it was just one long continuous kiss, but eventually I slipped my tongue into Will’s mouth. He let out a soft groan as my tongue played tag with his. 

Never in a million years would I have imagined myself making out with someone like Will. Maybe it was a little bit of guilt about how I’ve never paid attention to him. Maybe it was the idea of being pretty much all of his firsts. Regardless, I felt a strong attraction towards him. 

I pulled my head away as I broke our kiss. 

“You okay?” I asked. 

Will nodded his head as I looked into his eyes. 

“Good. Put your hands on me.” I whispered. 

Will awkwardly put them on my shoulders and I took a step closer, trapping Will’s dick between us. For a moment I concentrated on the feeling of his dick against the silky smooth skin of my stomach. 

“Lower.” I whispered. 

Will moved his hands to the middle of my back. It took all I could to not giggle at Will’s apprehension to touch me. 

“Lower.” I whispered again. 

Will slid his hands down to my lower back.

“Keep going lower.” I whispered, this time with a slight grin, tempting him to move his hands onto my butt. 

Will slid his hands down to my butt and I could instantly feel his dick twitch against my lower stomach. 

“There you go. You like that?” I teased. 

Will, now wide eyed, nodded his head. 

I leaned in and resumed kissing Will. As we made out once again I realized that his hands hadn’t moved an inch. He wasn’t even squeezing my butt. 

I once again pulled my head back to break our kiss. 

“It’s okay to squeeze and feel me up.” I whispered and resumed kissing him.

Will gently squeezed my butt and I once again broke our kiss.

“You can be firmer.” I whispered as I looked into his eyes.

“Are… Are you sure?” He said between heavy breaths. 

I nodded my head. 

“I just don’t want to hurt you.” Will mumbled.

“It’s okay. I’ll let you know if it hurts.” I whispered and began kissing him once again. 

Will then squeezed my butt with all of his might. Enough that I broke away from our kiss and my jaw practically hit the floor as I tried to adjust to the pain he was inflicting on me. It wasn’t an unbearable pain, but a pain that quickly turned to pleasure. 

I could feel Will’s fingernails digging into the soft skin of my butt. His grip was so tight I could feel my anus opening. I could feel Will’s dick twitch and throb against my stomach. 

“Oh god…” I whispered as I threw my head into Will’s chest.

Then he let go and a wave of relief washed over me. 

“That felt so good…” I moaned into Will’s chest. 

Then Will squeezed my butt again. 

“Mmm.” I grunted as I again had to adjust to the pleasure and pain Will was inflicting on me. 

I tried to roll with the pain, but I quickly found my limit. 

“Okay. Okay. Too much.” I whispered as I grabbed Will’s wrists and pulled them off of my butt. 

Despite the pain, I was incredibly turned on. I wanted Will so bad. 

“Let’s see what I’m working with.” I teased as I took a step back to get a better look at Will’s dick. However, the moment I took a step back, he covered it up with his hands again. I gently tried to move his hands out of the way, but he resisted. 

“Come on, let me see it.” I said, biting my bottom lip. 

“I’m just… Embarrassed…” he mumbled as he avoided eye contact with me. 

“What? Why?” I said kindly. 

“I don’t know. I feel like I’m so much smaller than the other guys.” he shrugged. 

“So?” I quipped back. 

“So I guess I’m just embarrassed. Maybe a little afraid you’re not going to want to have sex with me because I’m too small.”

I suddenly felt bad that Will had these feelings circling in his head. I stood on my toes and leaned closer to Will, putting my mouth next to his ear. 

“It doesn’t matter how big your dick is. I want to have sex with you. I want to be your first.” I whispered. 

I couldn’t believe such words had come out of my mouth. A week ago I was repulsed at the idea of having sex here, especially with someone like Will. Now I was practically begging to take his virginity. What has gotten into me?

Will cocked his head back and gave me a curious look. It was like he wasn’t sure if I was just setting him up or not.

I nodded my head and seductively bit my lower lip. 

“Come on.” I whispered as I reached down between us and gently moved his hands away from his dick.