Previous - Part 11

Moving In – Part 12

“Seth… why didn’t you tell me that Lauren was so cool?”

Alright, I had to have missed something here… first off, why are they all laughing together? Dani has only been down here for five minutes… there’s no way they hit it off that quickly. What are they giggling about?

And why did Dani say that… ‘why didn’t you tell me that Lauren was so cool?’… was she not in the same conversation as me? I told Dani that Lauren was flirting with me all week, then kissed me and sucked my dick last weekend. I feel like she should be upset with me in some way... Could her behavior be a front for her real feelings toward Lauren? What are her real feelings toward Lauren then?

What about Lauren? How does she feel about Dani? I never got the chance to tell her about Dani… so did Sam tell her anything? She seemed to be laughing and smiling along with Sam and Dani, but could that just be a front too? Was she upset that I didn’t tell her about Dani and didn’t tell her that she was staying with me this weekend? Or was she committed to keeping the ‘spontaneity’ casual?

So… what the fuck am I supposed to say to that?

“Ahhh… it must have slipped my mind. I had a busy day today you know…” I said, winking back at Dani.

Hopefully no one else noticed the wink…

“Hey Lauren, did you have a good week?” I asked, looking toward Lauren. She was wearing a baby blue sundress – the top was low cut, which accentuated her boobs, showing her near-perfect cleavage – while the bottom landed a few inches below her ass. She looked very sexy – since all three girls were looking at me, I did my best not to stare. “It looks like you guys got all introduced already... I guess that makes my job easy.”

I walked over toward my mom, smiling at Dani before passing her and grazing my hand across her lower back. Dani looked great too – she was wearing a small denim mini skirt that started around her belly button and nicely displayed her round ass. She was wearing a small green crop top, not covering much more than a sports bra – it clung to her and left nothing to the imagination. Her hair was still wet, so it laid over her shoulders, leaving a small damp spot on her top.

Sam looked nice too, wearing a pair of jeans and a tank top… but I really wasn’t paying attention to her, with the sexy Dani and Lauren standing on either side of her.

Why does everyone look so nice? Who are they trying to impress? Did Lauren and Dani dress themselves up for me?

Once I passed the girls, I approached my mom, and said “Sorry I’m late for dinner, Sam took forever in the shower, and I let Dani go first… Is there anything I can do to help with dinner?”

“That’s okay sweetie, the sauce needs to simmer for a few more minutes anyway… Actually, could you please grab some plates and silverware and set the table for dinner?”

“Of course, ma.” I responded.

I grabbed the plates out of the cabinet, walking to the table and passing the girls. I set out everything for dinner, returning to the island where the three girls stood, still talking quietly. This time, I stood next to Lauren, trying to listen and get a glimpse of what they were talking about – I never got a straight answer when I asked a few minutes ago…

Standing there awkwardly, leaning on the countertop around the corner from Lauren, I was still unsure of what they were talking about. I heard a few snippets here and there but couldn’t really put it together.

All I can gather was that it was something about boys, parties, and flirting…

At some point I must have stopped listening, after a bit Lauren looked at me and asked, “What about you Seth, have you thought about what college is going to be like?” Since I wasn’t totally paying attention to their conversation, I didn’t answer at first. Lauren turned her body to me, grabbing a hold of my left arm and shook it. “Earth to Seth…” she exclaimed.

“Huh… what did you say?” I asked, confused at why I was being shaken by the blonde.

“I asked, have you thought about what college is going to be like for you? We were all talking about the adventures and new experiences you get at college… and really all the new boys that are there. That’s what Sam and Dani are most excited about…” Lauren responded, while still holding onto my arm. She had moved her hand from gripping my shoulder, to interlocking her arm with mine. As I noticed, I looked at Dani to see her reaction. She had a slight smile and was looking curiously at Lauren who had her arm wrapped around mine.

That’s odd, she doesn’t look upset that Lauren is holding onto my arm. She looks more intrigued at it than anything… maybe she’s just getting confirmation of what I told her earlier. I feel like Lauren might be just being her flirty self, but I also think there must be a part of her that wants to ‘stake’ her claim on me… Little does she know that Dani and I were naked in my bed about 30 minutes ago…

I started to answer Lauren’s question, but before I could get anything out my mom called us over to the kitchen table for dinner.

My mom’s dinner was fantastic – we had a creamy chicken and basil pasta with some roasted tomatoes and parmesan cheese on top… so good. We sat around talking after everyone finished eating, my dad was seated at the head of the table, and I sat at the opposite end. Dani and my mom were sitting to my left, with their backs toward the kitchen, and Lauren and Sam sat to my right, with their backs toward the living room. The six of us sat and talked about everything under the sun – Lauren got the chance to know Dani and my whole family (me included) got the chance to learn some more about Lauren. It was nice to be around everyone and not have to worry about the subtext or pissing anyone off.

Amazingly, both Lauren and Dani behaved – not that I was expecting any outbursts – I was mostly expecting them to keep up the flirty banter with me and maybe exchange passive comments with each other. But they actually seemed to get along with each other – that made it significantly easier for me to be myself and enjoy having both of them around. As we wound down with dinner, Dani and I helped my mom clear the table and do some of the initial dishes. Once we finished and sat back down, the six of us decided to play a game. Despite complaints from me, we decided to play Catan.

Catan is a great game – but playing it with my family can be kind of… intense. I’m not sure if you could tell, but Sam and I can be a little competitive, and there’s a reason that we’re like that – my parents can be just as (if not more) competitive. So, I was a little nervous about how it would go…

The game didn’t go as disastrously as I expected. My dad won, no surprise there… but I ended up giving him a run for his money as it came down to the end. Dani was confused at first but got the hang of it after a few rounds. Lauren’s competitive side came out and she started freaking out at Sam a bit when Sam cut her off, it was cute and a little funny to watch them bicker.

I hopped up to go to the bathroom. When I returned, my parents were talking Lauren and Dani through the general strategies that they use – never enough to give away my dad’s ‘winning secret strategy’, as he calls it – but enough that next time, they would have a better chance at beating him.

My parents cleaned up the game cards and board, organizing it how they liked. Lauren and Sam were talking quietly about what they were going to do for the night, Dani and I talked briefly about what she could have done differently in the game. Dani of course, voiced her frustrations with the resources she chose, and I talked her through my thought process with choosing our starting positions.

My mom asked the group, “So what you all’s plan for tonight? Lauren, sweetie, are you staying the night tonight? You’re more than welcome to – if you are, I’ll just go grab the air mattress for you.”

Before Lauren could answer, I spoke up, “The air mattress is in my room for Dani…”

I looked at Dani, smiling, before looking at Lauren. Lauren spoke up “Yes, Mrs. Butler, I was planning on staying here tonight, if that’s okay with you…” she paused, smiling at me “Don’t worry about the air mattress, I fell asleep on the floor last time, but ended up sleeping in Sam’s bed… So, I’m good to do that again.”

I’m not sure who got that reference, but it was probably meant for me – She fell asleep on the floor, with me… so what was she saying that she was good to do again? Sleep in Sam’s bed, or what happened in my room? Maybe when I said that Dani was staying in my room, that got to Lauren a little bit… I didn’t lie and say that Dani was sleeping on the air mattress, but just that it was in my room for her.

My mom responded, “Okay sweetie, no problem. If that’s alright with Sam, that’s alright with me.”

“It’s all good with me, mom.” Sam said.

The chit chat continued for a few more minutes before my mom noticed the time. It was almost 11pm, so my mom announced that they were heading to bed. As they got up from the table, my mom and dad said in unison, “Goodnight, kids.” The four of us, who were still sitting at the table, all say our own versions of ‘goodnight’ as my parents left the kitchen. 

I looked at Dani and I could tell she was getting tired – she would never admit to it for fear of being called ‘lame’ – especially in front of her new friend, Lauren – but she loved going to bed early and rarely stayed up super late. Weirdly, Dani was also the type of person to sleep in until noon... I’m not sure how she sleeps so much, but it can’t be normal.

To the group, I made the declaration that “I’m exhausted, I’m probably heading up to bed soon.” That got a resounding ‘lame’ response from Sam and Lauren. I flipped them off, before looking at Dani and saying “Dani, are you ready to head up too? Since I know you got up super early this morning… plus, I don’t want you coming in later and waking me up.” This got a slightly annoyed look from Lauren, which kept her quiet… at least for a few seconds.

After her moment of surprise, Lauren spoke up “Damn… that’s lame. I was hoping the four of us would hang out all night. I thought we were becoming besties…”

I looked back at the blonde, saying “Yeahhh yeahhh, I know but we’ve had a long day. Plus, Dani drove all the way from Centerville at 5am this morning.” I paused, looking at Dani, “So… you guys have fun tonight, and the besties can hang out together all day and night tomorrow… how does that sound?” 

Sam and Lauren didn’t say anything, but after a few seconds, Lauren spoke up again as she pouted and crossed her arms “Ughhhh… I guess that’s fine…” As if she was already done with being dramatic, she continued “Ohhh, I almost forgot… There’s a party tomorrow night at one of my friend’s houses up the river. Her parents are LOADED and are out of town… so it should be a blast. Do you guys want to go with me?”

I looked around at Dani and Sam – I assumed that Sam already knew about it, so I focused on Dani. I asked, “What do you think, D? You wanna go to a party tomorrow?”

Dani smiled, saying “Hell yeah, I’m down to go! Just after I sleep for about twelve hours…”

“Alright, then we’ll be there… but tonight, we’re going to bed…” I said as I pushed my chair back and stood up, offering my hand to Dani to help her up.

Dani and I said goodnight to Sam and Lauren, leaving them sitting at the kitchen table. We headed upstairs toward my room, but Dani stopped off at the bathroom first.

As I entered my room, I collapsed onto my bed. My head landed on my pillow face-down as I star-fished across the rest of my bed.

My pillow. Shit… I never moved Lauren’s panties. Are they still there? Why didn’t I move them before Dani got here?

I fished my hand around underneath my pillow and found the panties. I pulled them out and held them in my hand, staring at them as I thought back to that night. God damn, I want to taste her pussy… Wait. Focus Seth. Dani will be back any minute…

I quickly moved from my bed and hid the green panties in my bottom desk drawer. Dani shouldn’t need to go in there, so hopefully that’s a safe place to hide them.

I laid back on my bed, this time laying face up – I pulled up my phone, checking my notifications. Nothing important… It’s probably because all the people that I want to talk to are currently in my house.

As I finished that thought, Dani opened my door. I lowered my phone, watching the brunette as she came into my room. It was mostly dark, but it looked like she had removed her makeup and at least started to get ready for bed. She walked in, closing the door behind her – she first went to her bag that was sitting on the air-mattress. She dropped her toiletry bag next to her duffle, then came and sat on my bed. She sat next to my left hip, resting her left hand on my chest. I threw my phone to my right, moving my left hand to rest on hers.

“Hey, you…” I said softly.

“Hey” Dani said as she smiled at me.

“Did you have fun? What did you think about tonight?”

“I had a lot of fun…” Dani paused, “Lauren is… interesting. I can see why you are into her…”

“Why do you say that?” I asked.

“Well… she’s gorgeous, she’s funny, her body is perfect, she’s athletic, and she has that perfect golden-retriever personality that I know you love.”

“Okay. I guess so… but it seemed like you guys were getting along?” I said, questioning, trying to get at what she was thinking.

Were they getting along? Or were they doing that thing that girls do – that whole ‘we’re fake friends, but secretly don’t like each other because we’re interested in the same guy’ thing? I’ve never known Dani to be that ‘fake’ type of girl, so I doubt she would act like that…

“I was getting along with her… and she does seem like a really sweet girl, and I’m sure that we could be friends… but I just couldn’t get the image of her sucking your dick out of my head.” She said as she trailed off.

Was she upset that I told her? Or upset that I let Lauren do that?

I sat up in my bed, turning Dani toward me. We both sat facing each other with our legs crossed, “I’m sorry that upset you. I wanted to be honest with you and tell you what happened.”

Dani’s head was down, looking to the floor and then at our hands, “Well, that’s the thing, it doesn’t upset me… Maybe its cause we’ve been best friends for years and you’ve told me about you doing things with other girls before, but it doesn’t really upset me.”

“So… then why can’t you get that image out of your head?” I asked as I grabbed both of her hands in mine.

Dani’s eyes met mine as she paused, thinking before saying, “I think it’s because I’m jealous that she got to do that to you, and I haven’t.”

I smiled. Dani was jealous of Lauren that she got to suck my dick and she hasn’t… well actually, Dani had blown me.

“Well… technically, you have had my dick in your mouth…” I said, keeping my smile wide.

Dani blushed, removing her right hand from mine, punching my chest, “Asshole… that barely counted. I had your dick in my mouth for less than 5 seconds before you pulled me up.”

Sarcastically, I said “I’m sooooo sorry… I was so turned on by you that I didn’t want you having all the fun. Would you have rather me not pulled you up and not rolled around naked with you rubbing our bodies together?”

“Well… I didn’t say that...” Dani said as she trailed off.

“Well… what are you saying, D?”

Dani paused again, eyes returning to mine, “I’m saying that I want to suck you dick, Seth…”

As always, thanks for reading! The posting schedule is going to be a little weird this week. Part 13 and Part 14 will hopefully be posted as scheduled tomorrow and Thursday. That means Part 15 will be posted on Monday, September 2nd... and the first unreleased part will be posted on Friday, September 6th! After that, I'll probably have to move to a weekly posting schedule for the new releases.

If you didn't know already, this is a repost on a new account. I am always open to feedback and comments about what you liked and didn't like about each part. The story is original and written by me - I hope you enjoy it! Follow for updates!