This post has been de-listed
It is no longer included in search results and normal feeds (front page, hot posts, subreddit posts, etc). It remains visible only via the author's post history.
The question is the title. I've been playing with this group for a few months now. Everyone else has been there for at least two years. Recently we had a combat where we had to make death saves for the first time since I joined the table. I'm first in initiative and about to roll when the DM rolls behind the sceen and starts on the next person's turn. I ask him for a second so I can roll my death save. He tells me he already rolled it and we're moving on.
I was kinda dumbfounded as I've never had a DM make a roll for my character without asking (especially a death save) unless they were intentionally trying to kill them behind the screen. I ask if it was a success or failure so I can mark it on my sheet. He says I don't get to know. Nobody else is reacting so I assume it's a normal thing with this group, but I've never seen it before. I stay quiet for the rest of the game and find out my character lived.
Afterwards I ask him if I can roll my own death saves, but he insists we're not allowed to since it makes things more fun if nobody knows who's dead. I found out that another DM in the same group also rules it this way, but has offered to let me roll and whisper the results since he thinks it unfair I keep stumbling into house rules nobody told me about.
So how does your group handle death saves? I'm curious.
Players always roll death saves. But if I can help it, I have the players roll their death saves and share the result only with me as the DM. It builds suspense more. And for the record, all rules are basically house rules, because all of the handbooks are merely suggestive guidance tools. It says so on like the first page of the PHB, I think.
Subreddit
Post Details
- Posted
- 2 months ago
- Reddit URL
- View post on reddit.com
- External URL
- reddit.com/r/DnD/comment...