So, I'm having trouble choosing a domain for my character-- it's the only thing I have to choose for them, everything else is relatively set in stone. Problem is, I overthink all of the domains and then I over-complicate everything by trying to be Creative^TM and Not Like Other Characters^TM. I second-guess the choice I made, I decide to rethink it, and the cycle continues. Instead of trying to write out all of my complicated thoughts on creating a cleric as a jaded agnostic player, I figured I'd try something new and ask for some feedback, maybe help inspire a different way of approaching this. For some reason, this character is proving difficult to create, as opposed to my monk and wizard characters before them.

So! Here's the character concept (and if you're my DM... well, then as long as it is a surprise to the rest of the party, David, enjoy what I've got so far lol): her name is Dafne, she's relatively outgoing but has spent the beginning of her 20's at home, helping her dads run their business as they age. She's a bit too comfortable in her routines and is a little nervous to step out of the nest and take a risk, but she knows it's the right thing to do for her self and her growth. She is a good cook/chef/likes food, but she's very particular-- for example, she loves fruit juices and scents, but she absolutely does not like getting dirty and thusly doesn't garden or harvest said fruits. She just cleans and juices and prepares them for dinner or whatever. She's kind of prissy and a homebody that way.

Dafne isn't afraid of killing in self-defense, but is afraid that she'll get too used to it and enjoy it if she is the one who deals the finishing blow often enough. Her main motivation (since I don't have one for the deity to charge her with) is that she wants to leave town to start living her life, but her secret motivation is that she wants to see hot people that aren't the same folks she's seen around town since she was young. So, she's a thirsty cleric who's ready to take the first steps towards growing a little more, and define herself as an adult away from her family and her comfort zones.

To separate her from my other characters, I want her to be more of a support character than an offensive/utility damage-dealer (my wizard) and a martial adept (my monk). I know that Life Clerics fill that kind of role easily, but I think they're a little one-note feature-wise (although, maybe there's some homebrew/reworks out there that spice things up). I'm trying not to make her your standard Cleric who has been devout her entire life, but I also don't want to go so far in the opposite direction that it defeats the purpose of playing a cleric instead of a warlock with some cleric flavor to em.

If this is not the right place to put this, then let me know! I'm really just interested to see how y'all interpret her (mostly) finished concept, if y'all are into it. Hope y'all can help-- if not, I'll ask my DM to help me out.