I've been posting around a bunch of subreddits, mainly this one, until I got the idea to start looking at the hometown pages where she went to college. I posted a couple pictures of her and asked the question.

Now when I do this, I'll typically get like 7 people that say they fucked her, but only one will be telling the truth.

This guy went to college with my wife, and they had a class together where they got grouped up for a project. In school they had been kind of flirty but that's as far as it would go.

One night, he was at a party and hit her up, she was at a bar. They were flirting at first, but then it turned into slight sexting. He told her straight up he's horny, and sent her a dick pic. She told him to come to the bar she's at. This next part is his words:

"So I remember pulling up and parking. Got in my backseat and pulled off my pants and boxers. I remember her entering the car and it was so fucking hot cause she immediately started sucking my dick without saying a word. I would stick my hand underneath her pants and just grab a handful of ass cheek (she was wearing a thong). After a bit more sucking (one of the best honestly. So sloppy) I pulled her shirt up and started sucking on her tits (you’re a lucky man). She took off her pants and thong and she told me to fuck her. I remember her telling me she was on the pill and if I came inside her it would be all right. I remember it being so fucking hot because there were people walking by and stuff lol BUT because of that as embarrassing as it is I didn’t last long. Her pussy was just so firm and tight and knowing people could’ve been watching us I came rather quickly lol"

He said they fucked missionary, and he came inside of her. She never hit him back up for sex, probably because he came quickly. He did show me his dick halfway hard, which was basically my size. I could imagine why she wanted his dick so badly.