Peg-leg Beth

Our rogue had been trying to find a prostitute every town they entered, I knew once he got into a large enough city it doesn't make sense for that to not exist.

I don't have an issue with him playing his character, but also didn't want to overly reward his horn dogging, so when they got to the tavern with the prostitutes, there were three.

A thin man, a very muscular man and "peg leg Beth".

She was a feisty redhead with a curvy body and her specialty was pegging. (This was mostly impromptu, it just came to me as inspiration mid session)

Our barbarian actually did take her up on her services and it made for some hilarious RP (we didn't get into details or anything, just rough summary using innuendo). I think the paladin did too later?

The rogue did not... and has admitted to regretting that choice ever since.

She quickly became a favorite character and has been referenced SO MANY times in and out of game.

The rogue stopped playing, but the legend of peg peg Beth lives on.