We have tried doing MMF in September and the guy was really hot in all terms and my wife enjoyed it too but we have to stop that in between because the guy penetrated without using condom which was very unexpected and we never thought it will ever happen. Although we have discussed it earlier with him for sex but didn't specified that we need it with protection and even when he penetrated me (H) stopped and told him to use the condom but he denied saying he will not cum inside so do not worry. It honestly spoiled my mood and my wife too was uncomfortable, so we stopped it by giving some lame excuse and didn't proceed further. Before the penetration the guy really did a great massage and lot of oral sex and I could see her enjoying. We did take few videos and we enjoyed watching it together and then we decided to delete it as we thought of not doing this again. Now I still imagine those moments and it make me hard and feel to give it a try again but with lot of discussion and terms/conditions with the guy before we proceed further. I haven't discussed this yet with her but I am positive she will agree too if I am comfortable.

What are your thoughts on this? Have you faced such situation before and how you dealt with it?

Please feel free to comment/advice.