cahutchins:

Thirty days in the end for 75, counting from the day he was pearled, plus a stack of pearls as reparations, to be split 50/50 between random and the Suilven militia. Additionally, 75's alt account to remain pearled and in storage indefinitely. We should approach some of 75's former victims, and see if they'd be willing to donate coal to keep the alt locked up.

Blakeisblake:

Thirty days in the end for 7583. Permanent pearling for MrSaturnCat555. Talk to 7583's former victims. Also, 15 stacks of pearls for reparations. One or two might be enough for us, however, this month of banishment should be a punishment. If we don't make him work for that month's time, he can just quit and come back in a month, not having had to work or spend his time in a useful manner to benefit us. Cman said that a person can collect a stack of pearls in an hour, so this would amount to either 30 minutes a day of work, or 15 hours overall.

letsplaycmansez:

We can't pearl him indefinitely, even though he's shown absolutely no signs of changing. Do they actually think he'll change his ways? He said he was going to before, and now 1.0 starts & he's right back to doing what he did in 1.0. If we let him out after a month and he goes right back to what he did, I'm not going to let the public control my decisions anymore. A month sentence, plus some 15 stacks of pearls split between Imperium & Suilven. The alt should remain perma-pearled to ensure that he is always one crime, and one slip up away from going under permanently.

Random902:

I like the 2 week/month long end pearls as reps, and the alt perma-pearled.

the2010og:

I vote 1 month in the end for 75 and indefinite pearling for his alt. As well as 15 stacks of pearls or obi as reparations and as something to force him to work during his sentence. Also a very explicit warning that that any crimes committed after his release shall be met with indefinite pearling of all accounts.

Ra_Ra_rasputin:

A long sentence, maybe two months? I am not sure. He has only shown remorse when his only way out (an alt) was captured. And even now he seems intent on confusing outsiders making statements about how he wanted to be peaceful but it was boring, and how he still has more alts? I am still a little confused. But the impression I get is that he is a renowned thief and will simply do it again if released.

Final consensus:

7583 is pearled for one month, and must gather 15 stacks of pearls. As a deterrent to future griefing, the alt will remain pearled indefinitely.