Coming soon - Get a detailed view of why an account is flagged as spam!
view details

This post has been de-listed

It is no longer included in search results and normal feeds (front page, hot posts, subreddit posts, etc). It remains visible only via the author's post history.

13
The dichotomy of Stargate ship energy weapons
Post Body

On WWW if you make a thread with post-Unending F-304s people will consistently talk about the gigaton range plasma weapons as if that was an unimpeachable fact. But really it is more muddled than that. All of the actual feats for Energy weapons that I know of don't get into what people would call "nuclear weapon scale" unless you flat out ignore parts of the feats.

There are the few "easily" quantifiable feats for SG energy weapons hitting a "neutral medium" (I.e. stuff that lacks possible exotic properties) that I know of,

There are a few that I can't remember if there are quantifiable showings (that /u/doctorgecko pointed out),

  • I would have to look at the siege of Atlantis episodes again but if the Wrath hives missed any shots then that would be another example.

  • The first episode of SG:U where the Lucian Alliance bombard the planet.

  • Yu bombarding Anubis's mothership while it was over Jonas's home city at the beginning of season 7.

And for the record I am not including superweapon feats in with regular energy weapon feats.

Of these you should notice a pattern, when viewed from orbit they are pretty good. When it switches to the close up perspective they could easily be replicated and exceed by any decent modern military.

So really to get any kind of kiloton scale firepower out of these feats you would need to flat out ignore the planet side shots.

The ways to get "clear" gigaton range weapons is based on scaling off of their nukes.

Which generally have pretty fucking fantastic feats. They also have a number of dialogue sources that routinely put them in the high megaton to gigaton range.

You do something like this, take the Ha'tak from Season 1 that tanked two, one gigaton nukes to it's shields with no issue. Then you take the Ori beams punching through two Ha'taks (which have been greatly upgraded since season 1) to say the beam must have exceed ~two gigatons of energy to bring down their shields and punch through the ships like that.

But really Stargate nukes are consistently shown to be far more impressive than their energy weapons. So I do not think this kind of scaling is 100% valid.

It would be like a character whom has no objective feat anywhere near planet busting, yet they are able to consistently hurt people who can tank planet busing attacks.

So overall I really don't think Stargate ships throw around as much firepower as most people on WWW seem to think. But I also don't think we should base their firepower entirely on the planet side showings as they don't make sense in the setting considering how weak they are. Dichotomies like what their energy weapons display certainly make finding a "right" number difficult.

Author
Account Strength
100%
Account Age
12 years
Verified Email
No
Verified Flair
No
Total Karma
32,008
Link Karma
2,854
Comment Karma
28,861
Profile updated: 2 days ago
Posts updated: 8 months ago
:Downstreamer:

Subreddit

Post Details

We try to extract some basic information from the post title. This is not always successful or accurate, please use your best judgement and compare these values to the post title and body for confirmation.
Posted
6 years ago