After the wild weekend Ted (Amy's brother) wasn't really talking to me. He was dodging me. Amy on the other hand was at my place every night. It was on one of those nights Ted showed up banging on the door. I went and answered. I wasn't going to let him in, he was clearly pissed off I was fucking Amy and not him. Odd situation for sure. Amy was wearing a long shirt of mine and that's it. It just barely covered her pussy. We'd been fucking 15 minutes before he knocked on the door. She and I sat on the couch and he was walking back and forth pissed off. He was talking like I had to make a choice between them. I said, Whoa, like fuck off. You don't get to give me ultimatums. Amy got up and went to the bedroom to get away. He sat down and put a move on me. I pushed his hand away. I stood up and told him we didn't have anything to talk about and I went and joined Amy in the bedroom. She asked about him. I told her Ted can let himself out. She was just getting on top of me when he came in. She dropped herself down on me. We ignored him. If he wants to watch, go ahead only, he didn't want to watch, he wanted to join!

Her ass was going up and down on me when he dropped his pants. He inched himself up behind her and I could felt his cock sliding in overtop of mine. Holy fuck! It felt very good. Amy was surprisingly calm and said, "Fuck off Ted" that's all though. She didn't buck him off or stop. She didn't do something dramatic. Here's this guy feeling it's okay to engage in a threesome with his sister. Double penetration and, by the way, she's small. However, it must have felt good for her too and she leaned way over and was necking with me as we fucked her. I could see around her, he had his hands holding her hips as he fucked her. He really wasn't fucking her, he was using her hole to frot us. This was a weird fucked up frotting session for him. So flipping bizarre. Amy announced she's going to cum and Ted too. Amy quivered and orgasmed. I felt Ted's man juice make our cocks slide extra slick. Amy knew I hadn't cum and after Ted pulled out I fucked her for another 5 minutes, then I came. By that time his thick load of cum was sliding down my cock coasting my balls with my load dripping down right behind it. Amy's pussy was totally gaping open from having two cocks in her. She leaned over. She could care less that Ted stuck it in her. Ted suddenly felt fucked up and took off. Amy laid beside me and was mad, really mad.

That asshole has been trying to fuck me every night since that football game. Wow! Taboo and he's jealous. Amy was mad but she was also a little turned on having had two cocks in her, and her first threesome albeit one guy was her brother. She was turned on by it. It hurt a little a first but once we were going and her pussy relaxed it was fine. She decided that as pissed off as she was about Ted being a dick she might be open to it again.

The next night she came over along with Ted. It was a bit different this time as when we undressed Ted and I were first in the bed. I was pretty turned on. Ted has a beautiful cock. I saw Amy rolling her eyes. Ted and I sucked each others cocks. I came in Teds mouth, and he shot his load a minute later. Amy was laying in bed. Ted went to go kiss her. She waved him off. "Fuck off Ted. No kissing." When we could get hard again Amy got on top of Ted, and was fucking Ted, I came up behind her and lubed her asshole. She looked back. "Oh. We're going that way today, are we? hehe" Yup Amy. Once I was in we got in sync. It's kinda hard to get in sync with the woman going up and down and I'm thrusting from behind, Ted was fucking upwards more than Amy going up and down though. He asshole was contracting non stop strangling my cock. I came in no time. I laid beside watching Ted sucking Amy's nipples as she fucked him. I was quite the sight. She was shaking as she rose and fell on his long cock. Her nipples were long and hard as he sucked. Amy quivered and shook then came hard on her brothers cock. She climbed off and Ted hadn't cum. I positioned myself and Amy lubed my ass. I let Ted finish in me. I could have just sucked his cock but I knew he wanted to fuck me anyways, so I let him. It was my first time and it felt so fucking good but it was a bit painful and I'm not sure about doing it all the time.

When we were done Amy says, "So Ted. Are you happy now?" Ted said, "Yup" Amy and me said, good. Same time tomorrow?