I am not real an avid commander mode player on bf4, but i like it. People never really obey orders but it isn't too bad. But in bf hardline it would be good if you were actually on the streets, not having a weird uav do everything for you. How you could be killed, and troops could be punished if they did not do as they were told, or if they took a wrong approach. It might sound harsh but i want to see something new and similar to real life. In real life, you won't be rewarded for disobeying and being too rough and violent, but at the same time it is a battlefield game and it wouldn't be much fun if you could not have 'all out war'