Authors Note: 

• I originally wrote this story for the r/Erotica monthly contest but was limited to only 3,000 words so I couldn't use the ending I had intended. This version reflects the original ending (another 600 words). Would love to know which is better!
• Although I use the same character (Amy Park) in my stories, these stories should be seen as standalone pieces, not chapters of a larger work. I like the idea that you can pick up any story at random and not feel lost if you haven’t read the others.

Prisoner's Dilemma

Amy Park’s heart raced as she stepped off the bus. The grueling five-hour journey from Mexico City was finally behind her as she stood in front of the most notorious prison in all of Mexico. Only a day earlier, she had been asleep in her quiet bed in California, her life turned upside down when she was informed her husband Scott had been arrested in Mexico City for drug trafficking—a charge so absurd it left her reeling. Scott was the founder of an environmental startup, working with the Mexican government to address clean water access for the country's most destitute areas. He could never have committed the crime he was accused of, but in this world of corruption and injustice, innocence didn't matter.

The imposing concrete walls of the prison loomed before her. At the checkpoint, a hulking guard with a lewd smile stepped forward, his uniform straining against his thick muscles. His eyes gleamed with a mixture of authority and arrogance as he leaned in, his height towering over her small figure, making her feel even more vulnerable

“State your purpose," he barked in heavily accented English, his eyes greedily scanning her body.

Amy cheeks flushed with embarrassment as she felt the guard's leering eyes roam over her, his gaze lingering on the swell of her ample breasts that strained against the tight fabric of her tank top. Her shorts, barely reaching mid-thigh, hugged her toned muscles and accentuated her long, tanned legs. Despite the oppressive Mexican heat, Amy regretted her choice of attire. This was not the impression she wanted to make, not when Scott's freedom hung in the balance.

"I'm here to see my husband, Scott Park. He's being held here," Amy stated, forcing her voice to stay steady.

"You're a long way from home, chica," he said with a smirk. “But follow me."

Amy followed the guard past the imposing gates and into the prison courtyard. She was led to a small, windowless room where Scott sat, bruised and broken. Amy's heart shattered at the sight of her husband. Scott's usually immaculate appearance was marred by cuts and bruises, his clothes torn and dirty. His eyes, normally so sharp and alert, were glazed with pain.

"Scott," she whispered, her voice catching.

He looked up, recognition dawning slowly.

"Amy? You shouldn't be here. It's not safe."

Amy rushed to Scott's side, "I had to come," she said urgently. "Tell me what's happening!"

Scott’s eyes shifted nervously to the guard by the door before speaking in a low, urgent tone.

"This is all a setup," he said quickly. "They know I’m innocent and said I can buy my freedom for $1 million. The company will wire the money—but the banks are closed during the weekend. The transfer won’t go through until Monday."

Scott's voice dropped, shame and fear evident in every word.

"But Amy, it's worse than that. I…I don't know if I'll survive to Monday." He paused, struggling to continue. "My cellmate…he’s a vicious psychopath…an absolute monster. And the things he’s saying..." His breath hitched. "God, Amy, I can’t even describe it. He’s telling me how he hasn’t fucked a warm body in months and that I have two perfectly good holes that will do just fine. Oh god, the moment I step back in that cell, he’s going to make me his fuck toy.”

Amy's mind went blank. She couldn't believe what she was hearing. She knew Scott wasn't exaggerating. The stories she’d heard about the conditions in Mexican prisons were enough to make anyone shiver.

“Scott, we need to get you out of here—now."

Scott shook his head, his voice trembling. "There's nothing we can do," Scott said, defeat evident in his slumped shoulders. The money won’t transfer until Monday. And the guards... they don't care. They’ll just watch."

Tears welled in Amy's eyes as the full weight of the situation crashed over her.

"There must be something that can be done. We can't just give up!"

Scott was silent for a long moment, his eyes distant. When he finally spoke, his words stunned her.

"Someone...someone…could take my place," he said softly, the words clearly paining him. "He told me…he told me…he wouldn’t touch me if he could get some pussy.”

Amy's mind spun in shock and horror. She couldn't believe what she was hearing. She shook her head, trying to make sense of what Scott was suggesting.

"What exactly are you saying?" she demanded urgently.

Scott's eyes brimmed with tears, his face contorted in agony as he choked out a reply.

"Amy, I... I can't believe I'm even saying this. God, I hate myself."

"He worked it out with the guard…if you agree, the guard would take you back to my cell for the night. And I…I wouldn't have to go back. I'd be safe in this room until Monday once the money transfers."

He gripped the edge of the table, knuckles white, his whole body trembling. Scott's breath came in ragged gasps, the weight of his words crushing him. "Oh God Amy, I'm so sorry, I'm so sorry. Please, just forget everything I just said!” He trailed off, burying his face in his hands sobbing silently.

Amy's mind reeled, her stomach churning with a nauseating mix of fear, revulsion, and heartbreak. The weight of Scott's words pressed down on her, threatening to crush her completely. Her body trembled as conflicting emotions warred within her - an overwhelming urge to protect the man she loved versus the primal terror at what he was suggesting. This was Scott - her husband and her soulmate. She would do anything to keep him safe. Even this.

"I'll do it," she said quietly. "I'll do it.”

Scott looked at her in disbelief. "Amy, NO! I can't ask that of you. The things he'll do..."

"You're not asking. I'm choosing," Amy said firmly, though her hands trembled. "I won't let them hurt you. We'll get through this together."

Scott's eyes welled with tears. He opened his mouth to protest further, but the guard interrupted.

"Time's up, let’s go chico." he barked.

Amy's eyes locked with Scott's, seeing the anguish and self-loathing etched across his face. She grasped his arm, attempting to offer him strength she didn’t even feel herself.

"You can take me instead," Amy whispered, her voice trembling as she looked up at the guard. "Just... just leave my husband alone."

The guard's eyes gleamed with cruel satisfaction as he roughly grasped Amy's arm. "Let's go then," he growled, yanking her towards the door. Amy stumbled, casting one last desperate look at Scott. His face was a mask of torment and regret as she was pulled away.

Amy’s heart pounded as she was dragged down the dimly lit hallway. The thought of what lay ahead made her body tremble. When they finally reached a heavy metal door, the guard pulled it open and pushed her inside.

"Wait...wait...will you be outside?" she asked, her eyes filled with desperation. "Someone has to make sure he doesn’t hurt me.""

The guard flashed a sly grin as he also entered the cell, shutting the door behind him. "Chica, what makes you think I won’t be having my fun too?"

The guard's words hit Amy like a punch in the gut as she backed away from him, realizing the gravity of the situation. She quickly scanned her surroundings, noting the bare cell with its rusty metal bed and worn mattress off to the side, and a large figure lurking in the shadows at the corner of the room.

“Meet your new cell mate, chica” the guard laughed. They they call him El Toro.”

El Toro, known as "The Bull," was a monstrous beast of raw muscle, his massive frame exuding an aura of terrifying power. His arms, thick with veins, were adorned with intricate tattoos that seemed to writhe and crawl across his skin, each one telling a dark and violent story. His broad chest rose and fell like the steady rhythm of an approaching storm, and his stance was that of a predator stalking its prey—unyielding, inevitable, and deadly.

"Well, well," El Toro purred, his voice low and menacing. "That little bitch actually sent his puta in his place,” he laughed.

Amy's breath came in quick gasps as the men closed in around her. Her eyes darted frantically between them, searching for any hint of mercy.

"Please," she whimpered. "You don't have to do this."

El Toro laughed, a harsh sound that sent chills down her spine. "Oh, but we do, chica. It's been so long since I’ve had a puta. And you're going to give us everything we want."

El Toro gripped the edges of Amy’s tank top and tore it open, the fabric ripping easily under his strength. Her breasts spilled free, her nipples tingling in the cool air.

"Fuck, look at those tits," the guard groaned, as he cupped Amy's breasts roughly, pinching and twisting her nipples until she cried out. Amy's chest heaved with quick, panicked gasps as the guard's cold hands traced over her body. To her shame and horror, she could feel her body responding to his brutal advances with a wetness that was building between her legs. She tried to focus on Scott, on her love for him and her determination to protect him.

El Toro's rough hands gripped her waistband and with one swift tug, he yanked her shorts and panties down to her ankles. She could feel the intense heat of the men's leering gazes on every inch of her body, causing her to squeeze her thighs together in a futile effort to maintain some sense of dignity.

"Spread those legs, puta," El Toro growled, forcing her thighs apart. His fingers probed at her entrance, as he found her wet and swollen clit. "Such a dirty little slut. Your cunt's already wet for us."

"F-fuck you…fuck you.." Amy protested weakly, hating how her hips instinctively rocked against his hand. "Get your filthy hands off me!"

But her body told a different story as El Toro’s skilled fingers worked her clit, sending jolts of unwanted pleasure through her core. He plunged two thick fingers inside her, thrusting them in and out with a frantic pace. His thumb relentlessly pressed against her swollen clit, sending waves of pleasure coursing through her body. She couldn't help but moan and writhe as he expertly stroked her g-spot with his curled fingers, her hips bucking against his hand.

"N-no…" she gasped, her legs trembling. "Don’t...oh please stop...please stop…"

El Toro's hand moved in a blur as he relentlessly pounded his fingers into her wet snatch. Amy felt the pressure building inside her, her inner walls clenching around El Toro’s fingers.

"Oh fuck… oh my god…" she whispered, her hips bucking uncontrollably. Amy tried to resist, but every touch sent shivers of pleasure through her body, confusing and angering her further.

El Toro laughed cruelly as he continued to pump his fingers in and out of her spasming pussy. "That's right, puta. Cum all over my hand like the little slut you are."

Amy's legs shook, her body arched off the ground, her muscles taut and trembling as the orgasm ripped through her. Her moan was a primal, animalistic cry that blended with the dripping and sloshing sounds of her wet cunt.

“Oh shit...fuck…fuck…fuck..." she panted, her chest heaving as she struggled to catch her breath.

Amy's mind reeled as the full weight of what had just transpired crashed over her. She felt dirty, used, her skin crawling where his hands had been. And yet... a traitorous part of her couldn't deny the intensity of what she'd felt, the primal rush that had overtaken her. Disgust and self-loathing washed through her as she realized a part of her had enjoyed it. But she had no time to process her emotions before El Toro roughly spun her around and pulled her to the bed. He pulled out his massive cock, a throbbing monolith of flesh, it's size dwarfing anything she had ever seen.

"Time to ride the bull, puta," El Toro growled, his calloused hands gripping her hips as he positioned her over his enormous shaft. Trembling, Amy straddled his muscular thighs. She gasped as the tip of his impossibly large cock brushed against her slit. Slowly, she began to lower herself, wincing at the stretch.

"Oh my god, it’s so big…it’s so big.." she moaned as he lowered herself inch by agonizing inch, the pain mingled with a deep, primal pleasure she couldn't deny. El Toro growled impatiently and with a brutal thrust, impaled her in one swift motion.

"Oh my fucking god!!" Amy cried out, her body trembling as El Toro's massive length filled her completely. Amy's body shuddered as she slowly raised her hips, El Toro's thick shaft sliding partway out before she lowered herself back down with a muffled whimper. Her movements were hesitant at first, shame and fear warring with unwanted sparks of pleasure. But as El Toro's hands gripped her waist, urging her on, Amy's pace quickened. Soon she was bouncing on his cock with increasing desperation, her head thrown back and breasts heaving. Sweat glistened on her skin as she rode him harder, faster, her cries growing louder and more frantic. Amy's nails raked down El Toro's chest as she fucked him, her body betraying her as waves of guilty ecstasy washed over her.

“FUCK…it feels so good…oh god it feels so good…” she moaned to herself.

El Toro grinned wickedly, gripping her waist as she bounced on his thick shaft. His powerful thrusts intensified, his massive cock stretching Amy to her limits. She could feel him swelling inside her, pulsing with his impending release.

"Take it all, puta," he growled.

With a final savage thrust, El Toro buried himself to the hilt. Amy's eyes rolled back as she felt El Toro erupt inside her. "Oh god, yes!" she cried out shamelessly. "I can feel you... so hot... so much cum!"

Her hips bucked wildly as her own orgasm approached.

"Fuck, I'm gonna cum on your cock…oh god I’m such a dirty slut.." The words spilled from Amy's lips before she could stop them. Hearing herself admit what she'd become - a dirty, wanton whore - sent a forbidden thrill through her body.

"Oh god, oh god," she moaned, her back arching as her climax peaked. Her nails dug into El Toro's muscled shoulders as her hips bucked uncontrollably.

But even as the last tremors of orgasm faded, a cold dread settled in the pit of Amy's stomach. What had she become? How could she face Scott after this? El Toro's cruel laughter echoed in her ears as tears of shame and self-loathing began to fall.

The guard approached Amy, his eyes raking over her trembling form. Without warning, he scooped her from the bed and spun her around, slamming her against the cold metal door. Amy cried out as he roughly kicked her legs apart, feeling his thick cock press against her exposed ass.

“NO! That’s my butt!” she screamed, “Not my butt!”

The guard spat on her puckered hole, using his fingers to work the saliva inside. She tensed, anticipating pain, but to her surprise, there was none. She was already dripping with a mixture of her own juices and El Toro's cum, making it easy for him to enter her tight entrance. The guard sank into her ass with a groan of pleasure. Amy gasped at the fullness, her body adjusting quickly. As he began to move, she was shocked by the intense sensations flooding her nerve endings. Each thrust sent sparks of pleasure radiating through her core.

"Oh god," Amy moaned, her hips rocking back to meet the guard's powerful strokes. Her fingers gripping tightly to the door as waves of ecstasy washed over her.

“Oh god fuck me, fuck me, fuck me please. You’re gonna make me cum….”

The guard's pace increased, his hips slapping against her ass. Her neglected clit throbbed, desperate for stimulation. Unable to resist, she snaked a hand between her legs, frantically rubbing her swollen nub.

"Oh god, oh fuck!" Amy cried out, her fingers frantically rubbing her swollen clit. "I'm gonna cum...I'm gonna cum from my ass!"

Amy's back arched as the most powerful climax of her life exploded through her body. Her asshole clenched rhythmically around the guard's shaft as waves of ecstasy crashed over her.

"FUCK! FUCK! FUCK!" she screamed, her whole body convulsing. "I'M CUMMING! OH GOD, I'M CUMMING !"

The guard grunted, slamming into her one final time before flooding her ass with his hot seed. Amy's vision went white as the orgasm seemed to go on forever, each spasm of her ass triggering another wave of pleasure. She collapsed, gasping for air, as aftershocks continued to pulse through her body.

Amy lay trembling on the cold concrete floor, her body aching and her mind reeling. As she struggled to catch her breath, Amy heard El Toro's mocking laughter.

"You enjoyed that, didn't you, puta?" he sneered.

Amy trembled as she pulled her torn clothes around her body, avoiding El Toro's leering gaze. “I hated every moment," she hissed, her voice shaking with fear and disgust. "I only did it to protect Scott. Nothing else matters."

But even as the words left her lips, Amy felt a twinge of doubt. The raw and unfamiliar desires that these men had awakened in her left her feeling ashamed and conflicted. She forcefully pushed them aside, determined to focus on keeping Scott safe until Monday, even if it meant suppressing her own pleasure and needs.

"Your husband is probably halfway back to California by now, puta," El Toro sneered.

Amy's brow furrowed in confusion. "What? No, that's not possible. Scott is in the other cell, safe from you animals."

The guard spat on the ground near her. "You really are a stupid bitch, aren't you?"

He crouched down, grabbing Amy's chin and forcing her to look at him. "Let me spell it out for you puta. Your precious husband isn't the victim here. He's the reason El Toro was in prison in the first place."

Amy's eyes widened in disbelief as the guard continued. "El Toro and his gang were caught running drugs for your husband. Your husband came here to bribe me and the other guards to get his people out before they could talk.”

Amy shook her head in disbelief. "No, that can't be true..."

El Toro leaned in close. "I told your precious husband I'd rat his sorry ass out if I didn't get my cut plus something extra to sweeten the deal."

El Toro's lips curled into a cruel smile. "He offered me drugs, a boat, a Mercedes...but I told him I didn't need any of that shit. Then he opened his phone and showed me his vacation pics of his wife."

"They were pics of you in that little bikini, tits about to pop out, ass cheeks hanging out. Said I could have you instead - use that tight body however I wanted. Fuck any hole I wanted”. His hand groped Amy's breast roughly. "Gotta say, those pics didn't do you justice, puta. That cunt is even juicier in person."

Amy's eyes widened as the horrible truth sank in.

“You're lying," Amy whispered, but doubt crept into her voice.

El Toro's laugh was cruel. "Am I? Your loving husband served you up on a silver platter. And now? He's long gone, leaving you here to pay for his mistakes."

Tears welled in Amy's eyes as the full weight of the betrayal crashed over her. She had endured so much, sacrificed her body and dignity, all for a man who had used and abandoned her.

As the two men's laughter echoed off the prison walls, the guard grabbed Amy with a wicked smile.

"It's time to eat," he announced in a foreboding voice that made Amy's blood run cold.

His meaning became horrifyingly clear as he roughly grabbed Amy’s ankles, spreading her legs wide. El Toro's eyes gleamed with sinister hunger, fixated on Amy's exposed and vulnerable slit. As he lowered his face between her thighs, his lips parted with anticipation and his breath was hot against her skin. Amy's eyes clenched shut in fear and disgust as she braced for what would come next. When his tongue finally made contact, she couldn't stifle her reaction - a sound caught between a gasp and a moan escaped her lips. Her body writhed involuntarily as an unwanted pleasure coursed through her, her hips bucking in protest even as she tried to resist the sensations

“Oh god not again…not again…” she mumbled, her thighs clamping around El Toro's head as his tongue probed deeper, circling her most sensitive spots with cruel precision.

Amy's back arched involuntarily as waves of sensation crashed over her. She clenched her eyes shut, trying to fight the rising tide of ecstasy even as her hips bucked involuntarily. Images of Scott flashed through her mind - his gentle smile, his loving embrace. But those memories were lies now, poisoned by the knowledge of his betrayal. How could he have done this to her? Led her into this trap, this nightmare of degradation and violation? The Scott she thought she knew would never have sacrificed her like this. As another moan escaped her lips, Amy realized with a sickening jolt that she barely recognized herself anymore either. The California housewife was gone, replaced by this writhing, gasping creature desperate for release. With her climax approaching, a single thought crystallized - the realization that something dark and hungry inside her had been unleashed and the only hope of surviving in this new and unfamiliar world, would be to fully and unconditionally embrace it.