**that are also cruelty free, vegan, fragrance and palmitate free lol

So I found a light coverage product that looks good that actually agrees with my skin and I can wear it everyday - yay! But now, when I cleanse with my Derma Sukin Hydrating Wash, it doesn't really take off everything that is on my skin. There is still a film of leftover product. I've tried using a few drops of squalane oil to break up the makeup before cleansing but it just seems that the cleanser is too gentle to pick up the product and wash it off properly.

So I'm looking for a new gentle, fragrance free cleanser that is also cruelty free and vegan but will still take off mild makeup? I was thinking of trying out the QV Gentle Wash again as I have used that on my skin before, but I remember it being slightly drying and can't recall whether it took off any makeup. I don't have much $$ for skincare so under $25 is preferred.

Routine

AM
Spritz with water
TO HA 2% Serum
Derma Sukin Daily Gentle Lotion
Sunsense Anti Aging Face Matte
Nyx Bare With Me Tinted Skin Veil & Nyx Can't Stop Won't Stop Concealer

PM
Few drops of TO squalane oil to break up makeup
Derma Sukin Hydrating Wash
TO HA 2% Serum
Derma Sukin Daily Gentle Lotion
Finacea 2-4x week

Thanks for taking the time to read - hoping someone can help!