See my post history for context. But very short version is early 40’s married cis het couple. No anal for years after unenjoyable (for her) early attempts to back-on-the-menu to trending AO now.

Anyway, yesterday morning we were fooling around in bed. She was little spoon and I was laying on my back with my arm under her neck and reaching into her shirt and kneading her tits and playing with her nipples. We both love this and I’ll do it for hours sometimes. She started rubbing my cock through my underwear.

After awhile I realized I needed to pee so I went to the bathroom to do that. While I was in there I thought, “It would be so hot if anal were just the normal expected outcome here with no discussion whatsoever.” So I quietly grabbed the lube from under the sink and went back into the bedroom. I don’t think she saw or heard me set the lube down on the bedside table but it’s possible she did.

I lay down next to her in big spoon position and start caressing her ass cheeks. After a few minutes of doing that she lowered her pants and underwear just enough to make her asshole accessible but not her pussy. And she left them like that for me. All this was done wordlessly. r/AnalOnlyLifestyle I nearly jizzed my underwear then and there.

I quickly lubed up some fingers and started playing with her asshole. Then one finger went in. Then two fingers went in. I finger fucked her asshole for awhile with two fingers and made circular stretching movements around the inside of her anus.

After she was nice and stretched out I put my dick in her ass and fucked it until I came in her.

I haven’t touched her pussy in weeks. Is she starting to prefer it in the ass? Either way, it’s hot AF and I think I’m on the path to AO!