Coming soon - Get a detailed view of why an account is flagged as spam!
view details

This post has been de-listed

It is no longer included in search results and normal feeds (front page, hot posts, subreddit posts, etc). It remains visible only via the author's post history.

35
All the Primarchs seem pretty bad
Post Flair (click to view more posts with a particular flair)
Post Body

I had this thought when thinking over the morality of the primarchs

But then i began looking at each and every primarch. Aren't they rather evil for allowing the emperor to continue as he was without starting an actual debate on the matter of how the men and women were treated in the imperium? having innocents destroyed to fuel the imperial war machine that went on to genocide the entire galaxy.

Like take Guilliman and Russ for example. Angry with Angron that he chose to stand against the emperor than continue as a slave. A slave to the imperial war machine that is fueled by the life destroying labour inflicted on uncountable innocents. Aswell as those billions of people being forced into millitary service with no choice in the matter, torn away from their families, sent to go die on some distant battlefield a day a week a month later. The injustice of it all never going answered as the primarchs turn a blind eye to it as they turn a blind eye to every horror befalling people of the imperium. Even someone like Vulkan is part in this hypocrisy. Now if they all viewed themselves as tools meant for a job and removed all emotion from the equation like they're robots i wouldn't be making this argument. But they are very clearly so human in their emotions and actions. They willingly followed the greatest tyrant in existence and cared not for the common man. If Vulkan and his sons were half as good as they pretend to be, they wouldn't stand for the treatment of humanity.

The primarchs decided to stand with the emperor and furthered his vision for the galaxy, expanding his tyrannical rule throughout the stars blind and deaf to humanity's suffering.

None of them are exempt, all of them are guilty.

Thanks for coming to my morality post, i had a blast writing this ^^

Comments

i had a blast writing this ^^

Well at least someone had fun. 🤨

Old Night was a 5 thousand year long techno-psychic Holocaust. When the alternative to Skynet is Napoleon it's easy to gloss over things that had been considered rounding errors for longer than we've had writing.

[not loaded or deleted]

But before that? How do you think the "good" Primarchs justified finding civilizations who had survived the long night, had stable governments with content populations

Becau--

(including on most of their home planets).

Because MOST of their homeworlds were actually pretty terrible and treacherous. People like Horus, Fulgrim, Lorgar, Jagatai, Vulkan, Corax, Curze, Angron or Mortarion all lived in incredibly repressive and/or terrible conditions before they fixed it using unrepentant violence and as such Big E never asked them to solve problems in a way weird or unfamiliar to them.

It's easy to mistrust peace when the only way you've ever seen it happen was through your own hands in a way that left nobody capable of breaking it.

[not loaded or deleted]

Why is this sub obsessed with the morality of 40k?

The puritans & 80s satanic panic moms won. Maybe not in the way they envisioned but their ideas about stories have been on a massive upswing.

[not loaded or deleted]

People always assume that the emperor saw a perfectly functioning, democratic state and thought „NOT IF I GET TO SAY ANYTHING ABOUT IT“, but no, if he hadn‘t acted, humanity would die out at a fast rate.

Debatable but I'm not even talking about De Emprah or the big picture here. I'm just focusing on why his Primarchs had zero reason to consider anything he did any worse than what the cultures they grew up in considered standard.

Well. Magnus opined because his culture had major issues with how Big E went about things but that was an exception and did not end well.

Author
Account Strength
100%
Account Age
6 years
Verified Email
Yes
Verified Flair
No
Total Karma
13,085
Link Karma
10,244
Comment Karma
2,678
Profile updated: 4 days ago

Subreddit

Post Details

We try to extract some basic information from the post title. This is not always successful or accurate, please use your best judgement and compare these values to the post title and body for confirmation.
Posted
9 months ago