It’s been a little while since providing an update since part 2.

Note: I had some people reach out for pics of Emily and Rachel. After some feedback on Emily’s boudoir pics, Emily has been upgraded to a C cup. Also I’ve apparently been underselling how hot they are.

To quickly recap, the previous time we tried to get Rachel pregnant (my sister in law), I fucked her as hard as I could while Mike (my brother in law) fucked my wife’s ass. This was 4 weekends ago, and this past weekend was the next time Rachel was ovulating.

After that night I had a one-on-one with Emily to get each others thoughts. I was curious why she let Mike both cum in her face and fuck her ass, when she very rarely (like it’s been years since either) lets me do that.

“Well the first part I didn’t really enjoy…def was not expecting his load in my face. I didn’t want him to cum in my mouth but I thought he’d maybe cum in a tissue or off to the side somewhere, I don’t know!”

“So you didn’t really care for it?”

“I didn’t love it but it wasn’t that bad. A little cleanup to do but considering how hard you were fucking Rachel it only seemed fair to Mike. You don’t feel the least bit bad for him in all this?”

“Of course I do but I’m just trying to help. Not sure how degrading you is fair to me or to you.”

“I don’t take it as degrading, he’s just having fun!”

“Well what about him going for anal with you?”

“That actually was really nice…no offense but it’s way more comfortable with his small dick than with yours. I loved the feeling of his warm cum in my ass. You should be flattered that you’re too big for my butt to handle. He was probably self conscious trying to stick in my vagina after you’ve been in there so much. I would’ve had to fake that.”

This really wasn’t making me feel better but I guess Mike just wanted to feel some control.

Fast forward to this past weekend. It’s been 4 weeks since the last time we tried conceiving and Rachel was ovulating again. Since the last try was unsuccessful again (expected), Rachel decided they wanted to try 3 nights in a row this time.

The bar for our foursome was set pretty high last time and I assumed we’d take a step back and focus more on the task at hand.

The night started late and they came over to our apartment after dinner. We poured a couple bottles of wine and played a game to get in the mood. I was in the mood pretty quickly seeing Rachel in a short slutty blue skirt and a low cut white tank top. We sat on the floor in a circle and played truth or dare.

Mike went first to ask the question to Emily. “Truth or dare?” “Truth,” she replied. “Is it true you liked having anal last month?”

She blushed or looked over awkwardly at me and Rachel. He just asked my wife in front of us if she enjoyed his dick in her ass. “Uhhh…I mean yeah I did. It was different, not really used to that feeling.”

Next Emily asked Rachel a question. “Truth or dare?” “Dare!” “Let’s start getting you in the mood…I dare you to spread your legs and finger yourself right here.”

Rachel stood up and pulled down her panties, stepped through them and laid them down next to her. She sat back down with her legs spread, leaned back and started rubbing her clit. She rotated between rubbing her clit and sticking her index and middle fingers inside herself until she was moaning and trembling. Mike stood up, pulled down his shorts and boxers and started gently tapping his cock against her cheek. Rachel kept touching herself and started to blow Mike. This was getting me pretty hard and I started touching myself too.

Rachel noticed and blurted out, “Truth or dare, John!?” “Dare.” “I dare you to eat out Emily’s ass.”

This was sort of a blessing, a nice peer-pressured reason for Emily to do butt stuff with me. Emily played along, stood up and removed her thong she had on under her dress. She put her arms on the counter and I got on my knees behind her. I lifted up her dress revealing her ass to the group. I heard Mike let out a soft moan as he came inside Rachel’s mouth. At the same time Rachel was shaking as she came as well seemingly.

I gently massaged Emily’s pussy with my fingers and started licking her asshole. After a few minutes, Emily’s legs started to get weak and she sat back as her pussy was now soaked. It was my turn to ask Mike to do something. “Truth or dare.” “Dare.” “I dare you to DP Rachel with me.” “Down!”

Rachel chimed in. “Are you kidding me? I’m not going to be handle that. I’m struggling enough as it is with just John’s dick!”

Mike followed up. “Fine then, Emily i dare you to suck on your sisters tits.”

Perfect suggestion. Emily stood back up and walked over to Rachel. She lifted up Rachel’s low-cut tank top and tossed it on the floor. Emily unhooked Rachel’s bra, revealing her perfect perky tits and started sucking on her nipples. Rachel giggled at the absurdity, Emily following suit laughing. Emily looked up at Rachel, “Sorry but this doesn’t get you out of your dare. If I’m taking your husbands dick up my ass, there’s no chance you’re not and then some. Don’t you want to be able say your husband was in you when you got pregnant?”

“Since when did you become such a stickler for rules?? Well then let’s get this over with!”

I took that as an immediate sign to get started. I led the group the bedroom. I had never been involved with a DP before but I’d seen it in porn. I was definitely worried with the mechanics and started to regret my dare. I took off my clothes and laid on my back on our bed. Rachel unzipped her skirt and she was now totally nude, revealing her cute happy trail. Mike took off his shirt and Emily followed to fit in. We were all the bed naked, just like last time.

Emily offered her help, “I’m here to make sure everything goes in the right place! I got you Rach!”

Rachel straddled me and Emily grabbed my dick to align it perfectly with Rachel’s pussy. Rachel started slowly making her way down my rock hard dick and paused and took a deep breath when she was all the way down to the base. She felt incredible, still super tight and soaking wet. Emily came over to the side and I started massaging her tits with one hand while grabbing Rachel’s with the other. Emily’s are definitely bigger I can confirm now after a good even feel test. This was the dream.

After a few good thrusts, Mike got behind Rachel to go inside her too. Rachel leaned forward over me, her hair in my face and i stopped thrusting while keeping myself deep inside her. Mike dripped a little lube on his dick and spread it around his dick and a little on Rachel’s asshole. Emily went around the side for a closer look, she was super amused by this. Mike gently put his tip against Rachel’s ass and pushed in, causing Rachel to shift forward more on me. After a few thrusts, he was in her now too but I continued to sit still. I was frozen, too scared to risk losing the position.

Mike started thrusting harder and harder I could feel his balls slapping against my shaft. Not ideal but this was my idea so I couldn’t complain. I started to thrust up and down carefully now too and Rachel let out a loud moan. That got me more jazzed up so I started going faster and faster until Rachel was shaking uncontrollably.

I came inside her and heard Mike let out a grunt as he came too and he pulled out.

“How was that?” Emily asked the group with a devilish grin.

“Painful! And you’re next!” Rachel replied.