If you haven’t read part 1 you can find it here: https://www.reddit.com/r/gaystoriesgonewild/comments/vrfzvz/sex_with_my_teammate/

I decided to actually make this into 3 parts because again, I don't want to cut out any of the details. Everyone in the story is over the age of 18, names are changed for privacy reasons.

Part 2

Tyler and I spent nearly every day over the summer together. We had workouts every weekday morning at 7 am and typically would grab lunch together after and spend the remainder of the day at each other’s houses swimming or playing Xbox. Eventually, we got to a point where we were just staying over at whoever’s house we were at and heading into workouts together in the morning. This also usually included passing out in the same bed together, and while nothing sexual ever happened - more often than not we woke up cuddled together in one way or another.

The only time we spent apart was with our girlfriends on the weekends. When we weren’t together he was all I could think about, being around him was so intoxicating. I had become addicted to him - his laugh, his smile, his smell, the way he looked napping in the sun when we were poolside. I couldn't get enough of him.

It was during this time that I realized my girlfriend never made me feel that way. I found myself less and less interested in sex with her, and even when I did give in to her Tyler was always on my mind. Erica and I had been best friends for years before I finally convinced her to date me, and now I didn’t have the heart to tell her that I thought I might be gay. But Tyler and I often talked about our relationships and he didn’t seem to be having the same problems I was, so I kept it to myself.

As summer ended and school started our time together was reduced to basically only seeing each other before and after practice, and some nights if we weren’t too exhausted or busy with school to hang out. Football season was right around the corner and after several months of hardcore training Tyler looked better than ever, his arms and legs had grown significantly, had developed a nice set of pecs, and an amazing bubble butt. With his increased physical fitness he beat out the senior quarterback for the starting position.

I was sitting in the locker room getting ready for practice after school, I was usually the first one there followed by Tyler so we can get some snaps in before practice started. Tyler comes into the locker room and lights up when he sees me. “Caden! Guess what!!” he beams at me.

“Hey Ty! What’s up??”

“I talked to Coach Grant after practice yesterday, he wants me to start in our first game next week!” He looked extra adorable smiling ear to ear, “I couldn’t wait to tell you! I haven’t even told my parents or Sara yet.”

I was so touched, he kept this news to himself for a full day to make sure I was the first one to know. “I’m so happy for you Ty, that’s amazing!” He pulled me into a tight tug. We stood like that for a while, my face buried in his neck breathing in his scent of cologne and old spice body wash, him slightly rubbing my back. I could tell he was enjoying it just as much as I was, my heart beating fast as I consider making a move on him.

“The fuck are you guys doing?” A voice behind us laughed. The intruder snapped us both back to reality, I looked over and my childhood best friend Jacob(a linebacker) was standing there gawking at us. “Hey Jake! Tyler was just telling me he’s going to start next week” Jacob’s expression softened “That’s dope man congrats, not bad for a Junior!” We all laughed and started to get ready for practice.

Tyler went to his locker a few down from mine and started changing out of his clothes. When he was down to his underwear I glanced over to admire his body and my eyes fell on his bulge, which looked even bigger than it normally does. I looked up at him and we made eye contact. I quickly looked away and started to feel my own cock stiffen. The locker room was getting pretty crowded now so I finished strapping up my pads and headed out to the field.

The following Friday rolls around and the energy is high as I walk into school, everyone is excited for the first game of the season. Tyler and I had not addressed our little moment in the locker room but things were still normal between us. I head to my first class and to my surprise Tyler’s waiting outside the door. God, he looked great in his jersey, and the shorts he was wearing outlined his ass so perfectly.

“Hey Ty, excited for tonight?” I greeted him with a smile. “Dude I’m so nervous I feel like I’m going to puke.” Football was a huge deal at our school so I totally shared that same anxious energy, but still, I reassured him it would be fine. “Dude you’re gonna be amazing tonight don’t worry! Plus I’ll be right there with you protecting your ass all night.” A look of relief washed over him, “Can always count on you to make me feel better, thanks man. Alright I better head to class, I’ll see you later” he said with a smile and walked off.

Long story short, Tyler was not amazing that night. In the first half, he threw 5 interceptions, 3 of which our opponents ran all the way back for touchdowns. Tyler was verbally assaulted by our offensive coordinator in the locker room at halftime in front of the entire team and was benched for the second half. I tried to comfort him before we headed back onto the field, but he shrugged me off. I was a little hurt but I had to go back to the game.

Before I knew it the game was over, and we had lost. It obviously wasn’t solely Tyler’s fault, the team just had an off night but he didn’t want to hear it. I’d never seen him that upset before and wasn’t sure the best way to respond. We rode the bus back to school in silence, however he laid his head on my shoulder the whole way home. When we got off the bus I headed straight for the training room to get ice for my shoulder, and met with the offensive line coach.

By the time I got back to the locker room, it was pretty much cleared out. Only a few guys were left still packing up their stuff. And then there was Tyler, sitting puffy-eyed in only his underwear removing the tape from his wrists. I walked over and stood in front of him, he looked up at me with puppy dog eyes. “Cmon man it’s not as big of a deal as it seems right now, nobody is blaming you - we all played like shit tonight” I said to him. He was about to respond but just shook his head and looked down.

“I fucked up dude. There’s no way Coach Grant will start me again this season” he said with a shaky voice.

“Ty the games over, we just gotta train harder and put more reps in. It’s just one game, it’s not the end of the world I promise” I responded with my best encouraging voice.

He looked back up at me, “Yeah I guess you’re right man. I’m just embarrassed and my dad’s gonna chew my ass out all night over this.”

“Just come stay at my place tonight, you know my parents won’t care. We can play Xbox and talk shit about how bad everyone else played” I joked.

There it was, that winning smile of his. He balled up that tape having finished taking it all off and threw it on the ground. He stood up and pulled me in for a(nother) hug. I was very aware that he was basically naked and enjoyed everyone second of feeling his muscled back under my hands. Again, the hug lasted longer than it should have until I felt something shift against my leg. He pulls back and hurries to sit back down to get dressed, but not before I got a peek at his chubbed-up meat. I gave him a smirk and walked back to my locker.

On the drive home, we stopped to pick up some food and his spirits had really picked up, we laughed and joked as we headed back to my house. My parents were already asleep when we got home, so we decided to eat in my room so we didn’t disturb them. After we finished eating it was shower time. By this point, I was exhausted and had been yawning for some time, but I still offered Tyler to use the shower first. “Dude just hop in with me, I don't wanna keep you up if you’re so tired” Tyler said as he got up off my floor.

My cock jumped in my shorts, but I declined because there would be no hiding my wood watching him soap up his naked body. “Okay well then why don’t you just go first so you can get in bed, you old man” he laughed as I rubbed my eyes.

“Deal.”

The warm water gave me a second wind of energy, and I realized how stupid I had been. Who the fuck would turn down taking a shower with the shining star of their spank bank?? I started to get hard thinking about him waiting in the other room, memories flooding through my brain of what happened the last time he waited for me to take a shower. I wasn't confident it would go anywhere but I had to at least try and take advantage of the situation.

“I’m almost done in here Ty if you want to hop in,” I said loud enough for him to hear me through the door. Much to my delight he opened the door a few moments later and began stripping down. I was unbelievably hard but said fuck it. I stepped out of the shower and grabbed my towel. I turned to face him and started rubbing the towel over my face and hair, making sure my face was covered - but my boner was on full display. Once my hair was sufficiently dry, I removed the towel from my face and looked at Tyler. Like I’d hoped his eyes had been glued to my hard dick. “My bad bro, happens after every game,” I said to him.

He looked up at me processing what I’d just said and became aware of his own hard cock trying desperately to free itself from his underwear. Finally, “No worries man - I spend like 80% of my day stiff as a board” he joked though he waited to see my response. I decided to just play it cool and wrapped the towel around my waist and walked past him into my room. I threw on some boxers and started scrolling through Netflix. I had settled on The Office right as I heard my bathroom door open.

“Dude I don’t have any clean clothes with me,” Tyler said from the doorway. I took in the sight of him in my doorway, nothing but a towel on with water droplets trickling down his washboard abs.

“Uhhhhh” trying to get words out, “Um I mean you can borrow whatever you want from me but we’re not exactly the same size” I laughed. “Actually I think I have some old boxers in my drawer you can try”

“Okay, we’ll see if that can work” Tyler responds.

I walk over to my dresser and kneel down to dig through the bottom drawer. Shoved in the back were a few pairs from when I was a freshman. I grabbed them and as I was about to stand up, I turned and Tyler was right next to me. My face was at eye level with his waist. I gulp as I look at the outline of the head of his cock pressing against the towel. I look up at him and he’s staring at me intently. “I found some that may fit you,” I say breathlessly while maintaining eye contact with him.

“Thanks, man, I’ll try them on right now” he responds. He reaches for the knot on the side of his towel and slowly undoes it as I watch. He drops his towel and I’m face to face with his massive, semi-hard dick.

Neither of us moves for what feels like forever until finally, I reach my hand up. I use my fingertips to gently touch the end of his head and trace them up the base of his cock. As I take hold of it in my hand, I can’t help but notice how heavy it is. I run my hand down his shaft back the head and Tyler moans softly. I then move my hands down to his balls and start massaging the golf ball-sized nuts hanging inside. His cock had continued to grow until it rested softly on my lips at its full length. I look up at him and he gently placed his hand on top of my head. Running his fingers through my freshly washed hair and I can see the desperation in his eyes.

I open my mouth slightly and gently place my lips over his cockhead. Still looking up at him, I see Tyler’s eyes close and he stifles a moan by biting his bottom lip. I direct my attention back down to his throbbing cock, and I run my tongue along the underside of his dick while I suck on the head with my lips. I take his head out of my mouth and lick all the way down the length of his 7-inch shaft. I bury my face at the base of his cock and take a deep breath of his scent. I lick my way down to his balls and alternate between licking and sucking each one, while I bring my hand up and start to slowly jerk him off. His hips start bucking into my strokes and I pull my mouth off his balls to look back up at him, still watching me with those gorgeous eyes.

I reposition my mouth at the head of his cock and pop it back into my mouth. I venture further down his dick, seeing how much of it I could swallow before choking to death. I got about 3 quarters of the way down before it was too much. I gagged slightly and felt Tyler scratch the back of my head encouragingly. I slid him back out to the tip and began long strokes up and down, savoring the taste and texture of this amazing dick as I start to really get into it. There was no initial discomfort I had always pictured there’d be the first time I sucked a dick, it felt natural. And really fucking hot.

I had established a steady pace and Tyler was going crazy grunting and moaning as I sucked his big dick. I noticed I was able to take more of his length the longer I went on, and so I went for it all. I choked immediately on the first attempt but on the third one, I found my nose buried in his trimmed pubes - my throat filled with his manhood. He let an audible “Fuck” slip out and I knew I had done well. It was hard for me to take him that deep on every stroke, so I settled for a solid rhythm of sucking half his length and every 5th stroke, going balls deep.

I’d been sucking him for about 10 minutes when I stopped to take a breath. “Damn you last a long time,” I said with a chuckle.

“I sort of jerked off in your shower, hoping we’d get to do this,” he said with a shy grin, “I knew if we did I’d blow almost immediately.” We smiled at each other and laughed. I asked if we could move to my bed because my knees were getting sore. “Of course!” he responded, and I plopped myself down on the bed. Then I received my second surprise of the night.

Tyler walked over to where I was sitting and pushed me on my back. He then climbed on top of me and started to lick and kiss my neck. I let a loud moan escape my lips, this had always been my weakness. He licked his way up the side of my neck and bit my earlobe. I couldn’t take it anymore, I grabbed the sides of his head and pulled him in for a kiss. A jolt of electricity was sent through my body as he swirled my tongue around with his own. My hands were all over his body, massaging his neck, rubbing his rippling back, and finally down to his ass. Fuck. I couldn’t believe how plump and firm it felt in my hands. I gripped each cheek hard massaging them and pulling them apart. I smacked his left cheek hard and he moaned into my mouth.

The feeling of his dick rubbing against my body was too much to bear and I scrambled to pull my boxers down without breaking our kiss. My cock, finally, free was dripping with precum as Tyler ground his own into mine. I lift his body slightly and readjusted my dick so it was resting in between his cheeks. I spank his bubble butt again, I grip his cheeks and use them to massage my dick while it slides between his crack. Tyler had begun gyrating his hips on me when the tip of the dick accidentally slipped in his hole. He quickly recoiled and broke our kiss for the first time, “Don’t get too carried away back there” he said smiling down at me. I lay there staring at how beautiful he is, I start to scratch his back and he lays back down on me. Back to kissing and sucking on my neck. I grip the back of his neck, trying to pull him as close as possible. My dick still resting between his cheeks as he starts to slowly grind and slide his ass up and down the length of my dick.

It was getting to be too much for me and I was nearing climax. “Ty we’ve gotta cool off for a second or I’m gonna bust all over your ass,” I say breathlessly trying my best to hold back my impending orgasm. He licks up the side of my neck up to my ear and whispers “Do you want to cum inside me?”

Before I could even respond he had spit on his hand and was rubbing it over the head of my dick. He looked back to line it up with the entrance to his hole. Once it was lined up and knocking at his door, he turned back and kissed me while simultaneously pushing back on my dick. My hips instinctively bucked and I slid in nearly balls deep. The sensation was too much for both of us, I started blasting cum inside him filling his guts and I grabbed his ass and pushed it all the way down on my dick to cum as deeply as possible. Tyler had a pained expression on his face and was fighting off moaning and crying. I pulled him in for a passionate kiss and gripped his ass hard as I rode out the last of my orgasm.

Tyler urgently pulled my dick out and plopped down beside me. He reached over to inspect his dripping hole, a somewhat pained look still on his face. “I’m sorry dude your ass was just too fucking tight, I didn't think I’d cum that fast” I say to him, worried that I hurt him.

He looked at me and laughed, “My ass fucking stings dude”

I laughed alongside him, “well let me make it up to you.” I looked down at his massive dick standing at attention. “I don't think I’m ready to try and take that beast in my ass, but I really want to swallow your cum.”

“Yes please,” he smiled at me. I kissed him again for a few seconds and then proceeded to lick and kiss his neck down to his chest. I took his left nipple into my mouth, which elicited a moan from Tyler. I swirled my tongue around his nipple and gave it a few nibbles while I jerked his cock. I continued my way down licking his stomach which had a light mist of sweat on it and even dipped my tongue into his belly button which made him squirm.

I had arrived at his dick and licked my way up his shaft, stopping to kiss and tease his head before I swallowed him. I was struggling again to take him all the way when I had an idea taken from some porn I had watched. “Ty, get up and stand in front of the bed” he looked at me confused and disappointed I’d taken my mouth off his dick, but did what I said. I laid on my back and hung my head over the edge of the bed and he quickly figured out what I was doing.

“Just go slow at first” I pleaded as he dragged the head of his cock across my face. He winked at me and pushed my mouth open with his hand. His cock slid into my mouth and I tried to use my tongue to lick it as it went through, though I quickly realized that was going to make me choke. Soon he had completely buried his dick down my throat as I inhaled his manly scent.

He pulled back out to the head and asked if I was okay breathing, I nodded and grabbed the back of his legs to push his dick back in my mouth. He groaned once he bottomed out in my throat and said, “Fuckkkkk dude, Sara’s never taken me this deep before.” He leaned over and put his hands on the bed to support himself, and started to fuck my throat. I struggled heavily at first trying to time my breathing right and to fight off my gag reflex. By the time he was really into it, I had tears in my eyes and was positive I was going to have a black eye from his balls slapping against my face so hard. After 5ish minutes of this, he told me he was getting close. I grabbed his butt to let him know I was ready for it.

His rhythm became a little frantic and I could feel him swelling inside my mouth. Right as he was about to finish, he bent down and slipped my own dick into his mouth. God, I was in fucking heaven. His cock pulsed more and more until he thrust into me one final time and shot his load down my throat. I did my best with my mouth and tongue to massage his dick as he came inside me. I could feel him moaning all over my dick and I almost shot a second load then and there. Unfortunately, I was completely out of air and had to tap him on his side to pull out.

He laid down on his back next to me and I sat up to catch my breath. He played with my dick absentmindedly as he watched my ceiling fan. Neither of us said anything for several minutes until he asked me where his towel was. He went over and picked it up from its spot on my floor, and grabbed the pair of boxers I had offered to him. He went into the bathroom and closed the door. I checked my phone while he was in there and it was almost 1 am, only 4 hours before we needed to get up and get ready to head to the field.

I put my own pair of boxers back on and sat on my bed, waiting for him to come out of the bathroom. He was in there for a long time and I had started to doze off before he finally emerged. I scooted over in my bed and lifted the covers so he could get underneath with me. Instead, he grabbed a different blanket from the end of my bed and covered himself with that. He laid down facing away from me without saying anything.

I sat up in bed, “Are you mad that we did that Ty?” I asked him.

Without rolling over to look at me, he simply answered “Nah man I’m just really tired and we’ve got to get up soon.”

I was a little hurt that he didn’t want to cuddle, and sad he was acting weird, but honestly, I was too tired to care that much and laid back down and fell asleep.