This is just one I've been having a hard time splitting my thoughts on, and I've seen people on here touching on as well.

If Bethesda dropped this as a new Fallout game, yeah I'd have some complaints. Load times, level design, NPC's could use more dialogue, etc.

However, as a fan made mod, it gets a little weird. Cause it's a jaw dropping feat of a mod. It's massive, polished, and there's so much new stuff that you do start to think of it more as its own game. That fact alone is insane for a mod. So looking at it from that angle, the feeling is, "Yeah I have some complaints, but look at it!"

Last thing I'll say on it is there is something to be said for artistic intent. Like if the intent is to make essentially a new dlc/game, is it fair then to judge it on how well/poorly it met that goal? What do y'all think?