Coming soon - Get a detailed view of why an account is flagged as spam!
view details

This post has been de-listed

It is no longer included in search results and normal feeds (front page, hot posts, subreddit posts, etc). It remains visible only via the author's post history.

6
Over 2022 I Have Read 37546 Pages Across 180 Titles and Given Them a Rating
Post Flair (click to view more posts with a particular flair)
Author Summary
CanadianGuitar is age 75
Post Body

I picked up the comic collecting and reading habit in January of 2021, and was hooked quickly. 2022 only saw the habit [obsession] grow, and I decided after reading a few good titles to kick off the year, to start reviewing them.

What started as a sentence or two, turned into a paragraph or two eventually, and by June, I was reading faster than I was reviewing, and it became overwhelming, and I had to drop the reviews and stick to the number rating I was giving them. At times, I had 7 or 8 books I needed to review, but was needing to reskim them to write the reviews - it became a mess.

In the link below is my full list of titles read, with format, author, ratings, page counts and a few minor notes. The ratings are 1-100, with the rating encompassing Story/Writing, Artwork, and Enjoyability/Connection (Some books while not as "good" as others, I connected with thematically more which gets a point or two bump here and there). As I read and added to my list, ratings got tweaked up or down a point to slot books above or below depending on enjoyment relative to other books.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kbGD4Q3taM5QdMHLNrt9ec3Y-tYqlu9HcQQcgpO75KE/edit?usp=sharing

[Format Legend: TPB = Trade Paper Back HC = Hard Cover SI = Single Issue OS = One Shot PF = Prestige Format]

Some takeaways or quick notes:

  • The 37546 Pages over 180 Titles averaged 208.6 Pages per title. Even though I entered the entire Hero Alliance "universe" (Original run, second run, all annuals/quarterly's, etc), removing it only changes this it 203.9 Pages per title.
  • Of the 180 titles, 17 were Black Label titles or 9.4%. These had an average rating of 78.8 which was slightly pulled down by my very middling feelings/rankings on The Question: The Deaths of Vic Sage. Removing this, the average rating of Black Label titles was 80.6. I think the alternative storyline and ways of thinking often lead to an interesting read, and for the most part, Black Label titles will be something unique and fairly enjoyable
  • The three writers who appeared most (not including those who wrote as part of anthologies [Various])
  1. Stjepan Sejic 8 Titles - Averaging 84.4
  2. Brian Michael Bendis 7 Titles - Averaging 68.7 (Hurt by Checkmate)
  3. Tom King 6 Titles - Averaging 85.3
  • 91.7% of the titles were published by DC, followed secondly by Image at 5.5%

The lowest ranked titles I've read:

  1. Batman Vs. Ra's Al Ghul 18
  2. Metal Men 23
  3. Hawk and Dove Annual #2 (1991) 43
  4. Checkmate 43
  5. The Question: The Deaths of Vic Sage 50
  6. Cosmic Odyssey #1-4 52
  7. RWBY/Justice League 53
  8. Metamorpho: Two Worlds, One Destiny 55
  9. Gen 13 Interactive #1-3 56
  10. Aquaman/Green Arrow - Deep Target 57

And finally, the highest rating titles I've read of the 2022 Calendar year:

  1. The Other History of the DC Universe 98
  2. Mister Miracle Deluxe 96
  3. Far Sector 96
  4. Batman: The Imposter 94
  5. Harley Quinn Black White Red 91
  6. The Human Target Volume One 91
  7. Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow 90
  8. Teen Titans Vol. 3: Seek and Destroy 89
  9. Static: Season One 89
  10. Robin Vol. 2: I Am Robin 89
  11. Sunstone Volume 7 89

Hopefully this can point people to a few good reads they wouldn't normally, or perhaps avoid a few I really didn't like. It was a fun year buying and reading all of these, and I look forward to another year of burying myself in books and lore.

Remember - these are my rankings/rating and opinions. This doesn't mean you, or anyone else can't like things I didn't, or hate things I enjoyed. We all like different things, go read and make your own opinions!

Author
Account Strength
100%
Account Age
8 years
Verified Email
Yes
Verified Flair
No
Total Karma
63,742
Link Karma
12,970
Comment Karma
49,940
Profile updated: 5 days ago
Posts updated: 1 year ago

Subreddit

Post Details

Age
75
We try to extract some basic information from the post title. This is not always successful or accurate, please use your best judgement and compare these values to the post title and body for confirmation.
Posted
1 year ago