While I was a freshman in college (19M at the time), I started dating a girl who lived in my dorm. She was 19 at the time. We had a very good sex life, screwing everyday. She also had a kinky side and liked to be full of my cum before going to class or come back to her dorm room after a shower wearing only a robe, get on her knees and let me jerk off into her mouth so she could swallow.

Anyways, after having sex one night we laid in bed having pillow talk. She mentioned the idea of having a threesome with another woman and said she loved the idea of watching me with another woman. Out of curiosity I asked her who she'd want this other woman to be. She blurted out a mutual friend we had named Beth (name changed for this). Beth was easily one of the more attractive women we hung out but the problem was Beth was dating a guy who was much older. She was 19, like us, and her BF was in his mid-30's. He was an absolute douche. Very controlling, manipulative, jealous, etc. We found out over time he also was emotionally abusive. Anyways, one Saturday night, Beth was hanging with her BF and called my GF crying. Her BF tried to choke her out at a party when he was drunk and angry. She needed a ride to take her back to campus. We arranged one for her since we were also drinking and in no condition to drive.

We didn't see Beth until the next Friday night. She came to my GF's dorm room so they could talk. Drinking was involved and it never took many drinks for my GF to get horny. Eventually she started to put the moves on me and I was reluctant since we weren't alone but couldn't resist her touch. We got into her bed and stripped naked. In the heat of the moment, we heard Beth say, "No fair, you guys get to fuck and I'm all alone." My GF and I looked at each other and my GF blurted out, "Get your ass up here!" Then I hear Beth climb into the bed. I'm laying on my back, stark naked, hard cock in the air for her to see. She only replied with, "Nice!" (Always makes a guy feel good). She stripped down and I will always remember the small tattoo on her upper thigh of some birds and music notes. Beth crawls between my legs and leans over me to kiss my GF. I had butterflies in my stomach and jumped some when the tip of my cock brushed her skin. It was so soft!!!

Beth then straddles me and is about to lower herself onto my cock. Finally! A fantasy about to come true!!! She hesitated though and decided against having sex because she technically never broke up with her BF and didn't want to cheat.

My GF and I were disappointed as Beth got dressed and left.

We still had amazing sex without her though!